nielliesmons on Nostr: Nostr is great for private groups. As in private property 👉 Keys, Community Relays ...

Nostr is great for private groups.

As in private property 👉 Keys, Community Relays (and media servers, mints, computation...)
Not as in secrecy 👉 simplex (npub1exv…d828)

quoting
nevent1q…rye2

If Simplex already does this (and arguably way better) then why would this bring people to Nostr?

There's nothing novel here. Not even for the supersecret activists. Also, why would they even want to tie their npub to any of it?

Ratchets are crappy UX on an open protocol rich in all these other content types.

All this quadruple ratcheting also ignores Relays as more efficient and interoperable solutions for 90% of what they're trying to do.

Chat relays, btw, are where an actual UVP can be found. They can be the Telegram 10x experience you encryption-schene-geeks keep hyping people into.