Here's why I find using the d-tag confusing.
If I want to rate the book "Jane Eyre", then I can refer to it by an `a` tag in that `d` tag, and that would give me a review of some particular edition of the book.
If I want to rate the book `Jane Eyre`, as a general novel, then the `d` tag would have to contain another `d` tag, which could refer to the novel as a publication, a wiki page about the novel, an audiobook about the novel, an article about the novel, etc. So, the disambiguation page for "jane-eyre" would have the rating from that d-tag, but not from the other d-tag, correct?
But, if I put an `i` tag to the ISBN in the `d` tag, then it would be rating a different subset, i.e. the publications containing that `i` tag, including from kinds we don't support, and books off-Nostr. And it would exclude all publication events that don't have an ISBN number, even if they were for the same book.
Silberengel
npub1l5…egx9z
2025-05-08 10:00:05
in reply to nevent1q…tqtm
Author Public Key
npub1l5sga6xg72phsz5422ykujprejwud075ggrr3z2hwyrfgr7eylqstegx9zPublished at
2025-05-08 10:00:05Event JSON
{
"id": "b4ccbfbdd424e2cba1b3dce83e4d7ca237e1ae4586858eb1e987c5586db472a2",
"pubkey": "fd208ee8c8f283780a9552896e4823cc9dc6bfd442063889577106940fd927c1",
"created_at": 1746698405,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"21ebb10aa6d51abd9462a2a6ea8d9532a5484741afc48e95e2f4bb4d28053747",
"",
"root",
"fd208ee8c8f283780a9552896e4823cc9dc6bfd442063889577106940fd927c1"
],
[
"e",
"e2026e328e2ed0f7b0b5a6710f0be6dd1410e77e69614f707b55e312f85eab9e",
"wss://nos.lol/",
"reply",
"fd208ee8c8f283780a9552896e4823cc9dc6bfd442063889577106940fd927c1"
],
[
"p",
"c21b1a6cdb247ccbd938dcb16b15a4fa382d00ffd7b12d5cbbad172a0cd4d170"
]
],
"content": "Here's why I find using the d-tag confusing.\n\nIf I want to rate the book \"Jane Eyre\", then I can refer to it by an `a` tag in that `d` tag, and that would give me a review of some particular edition of the book.\n\nIf I want to rate the book `Jane Eyre`, as a general novel, then the `d` tag would have to contain another `d` tag, which could refer to the novel as a publication, a wiki page about the novel, an audiobook about the novel, an article about the novel, etc. So, the disambiguation page for \"jane-eyre\" would have the rating from that d-tag, but not from the other d-tag, correct?\n\nBut, if I put an `i` tag to the ISBN in the `d` tag, then it would be rating a different subset, i.e. the publications containing that `i` tag, including from kinds we don't support, and books off-Nostr. And it would exclude all publication events that don't have an ISBN number, even if they were for the same book.",
"sig": "376082e8810594252915084d963857cf67549fd68a0f0d82cec115fe4374c19701bd33b41a1fa6a86cc104e3b8e9ea19e8356c410212df5aa82485f123b9203b"
}