npub1yhj4ua6580h3w0kucwwrtwl4uv9pg7m2drxzplq5x3364jczp36s4h3h3t (npub1yhj…3h3t) Out of genuine curiosity, and I guess npub1slyc6w2fy6t7sk7e5caxclu2dn629l35n4tkjyxzrqndkpq86x2sfut8j7 (npub1sly…t8j7) also has something to say here: 10-20 years ago, there was the (still ongoing) debate on filesharing and media piracy. One of the arguments there was "look, you cannot meaningfully crack down on this due to technology, and if you do anyway, the societal costs would be too high".
That sounds eerily familiar to what the big AI proponents say today.
So, is their argument equally valid? And if not, why? (My gut feeling is that the societal cost for regulating the AI business models is a lot less than completely prohibiting filesharing. On top of that, filesharing is mostly only forbidden because copyright is borked - but then, isn't copyright one of the main venues of argument by those who critize OpenAI et al?
JollyOrc /
npub1js…sfnha
2024-01-19 11:39:41
in reply to nevent1q…rpp0
Author Public Key
npub1js7yxxawnmffpxy7qda5pt2ckkxjxvqntnp3fdckw8unffu5gwusysfnhaPublished at
2024-01-19 11:39:41Event JSON
{
"id": "09e085fa0ca788876f721fe3ea4f06efd7340a410a046b5449e9525c95f1a68f",
"pubkey": "943c431bae9ed290989e037b40ad58b58d2330135cc314b71671f934a79443b9",
"created_at": 1705664381,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"25e55e77543bef173edcc39c35bbf5e30a147b6a68cc20fc143463aacb020c75",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"87c98d39492697e85bd9a63a6c7f8a6cf4a2fe349d576910c21826db0407d195",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"6e5bb3f4df765d024066fb8b1b0ab196b68726b8092782a387c9698fd05d8c35",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"6527ed4b3886f3e9a14483f38015e966febecb851259510ff54cb2cebfc4e6fa",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"e",
"4cdd1ff9f0cff5ae56e6c0abc2af58e6eb7cd44dd322e2661e03685e20919092",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub",
"reply"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://social.5f9.de/users/jollyorc/statuses/111782420932295773",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "nostr:npub1yhj4ua6580h3w0kucwwrtwl4uv9pg7m2drxzplq5x3364jczp36s4h3h3t Out of genuine curiosity, and I guess nostr:npub1slyc6w2fy6t7sk7e5caxclu2dn629l35n4tkjyxzrqndkpq86x2sfut8j7 also has something to say here: 10-20 years ago, there was the (still ongoing) debate on filesharing and media piracy. One of the arguments there was \"look, you cannot meaningfully crack down on this due to technology, and if you do anyway, the societal costs would be too high\".\n\nThat sounds eerily familiar to what the big AI proponents say today.\n\nSo, is their argument equally valid? And if not, why? (My gut feeling is that the societal cost for regulating the AI business models is a lot less than completely prohibiting filesharing. On top of that, filesharing is mostly only forbidden because copyright is borked - but then, isn't copyright one of the main venues of argument by those who critize OpenAI et al?",
"sig": "8bcf7d3d05bda43b4f801c98bb190486acc924962d9f3ec493a5aff94138d5b68ebbc45f882a90aeb588dd6003c108cc242fd768f77b7b42033c5ca7ac63136d"
}