npub1qag4apwpga64u32qkph92cetzfswcwgglcjg2txha3puzmgxwuws5p9gyn (npub1qag…9gyn) Yes you are right up to a point, but if you look at the actual case law, such as the recent Warhol case, the legal line is not quite "small or remixed sample fine, big or verbatim sample bad".
The Supreme Court have made clear that SUBSTITUTION is one of the key tests.
Everyone is entitled to earn a living. If what you're doing would substantially replace the business income of the original artist, it's infringing.
Even small bits can infringe if the ORIGINAL use might have been small.
Matt Lavender /
npub1tj…xdks9
2024-01-12 14:16:51
in reply to nevent1q…wnde
Author Public Key
npub1tj44u0uwzm5anxputagdnxz7qjsf6ggaws4leqla6f7hqq0a30ns7xdks9Published at
2024-01-12 14:16:51Event JSON
{
"id": "8cb083e85709cec545cb50af1a8a92fbaf9a7e86a91c5d8aee8fb3c844d977b9",
"pubkey": "5cab5e3f8e16e9d9983c5f50d9985e04a09d211d742bfc83fdd27d7001fd8be7",
"created_at": 1705069011,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"07515e85c147755e4540b06e55632b1260ec3908fe24852cd7ec43c16d06771d",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"19f681e034e87cdbcf4346fe68ca0e61653e30b8331a8ec4e639746947a39ed5",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"e",
"e0f36e84b9c430fcb206e24f53e967ff3ae6c06dc98bff4199d576da7dfcf881",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub",
"reply"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://journa.host/users/mattlav1250/statuses/111743402736698441",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "nostr:npub1qag4apwpga64u32qkph92cetzfswcwgglcjg2txha3puzmgxwuws5p9gyn Yes you are right up to a point, but if you look at the actual case law, such as the recent Warhol case, the legal line is not quite \"small or remixed sample fine, big or verbatim sample bad\".\n\nThe Supreme Court have made clear that SUBSTITUTION is one of the key tests.\n\n Everyone is entitled to earn a living. If what you're doing would substantially replace the business income of the original artist, it's infringing.\n\nEven small bits can infringe if the ORIGINAL use might have been small.",
"sig": "1b1307eadccc807078b62c7fca2c7e8a471b6e70f712d72e34309b98b18dc0a1123571d1b9117007c490e90d9fffe184a5c68c4b9f80873245c9472d2d7cb854"
}