Mmm…you say “can”. I’m thinking we should consider if it “should”. I predict a *lot* of spammy broadcasting posts otherwise. People can obviously sift by chosing not to follow those accounts but…
It would make sense to be able to control the audience of a post, that indeed seems to be a requested feature, but personally I fail to see why I should be able to broadcast to “everyone” and then just pick a handful of people who can interact with my post.
The other way around, I am thinking if I limit who can interact with my post, it should **also** *only* be delivered to those people. It kind of “comes with the deal”. It also sounds rather fair (which obviously will be the main reason to why it’ll never happen).
To me, the general rule would be: “if you can read it you can interact with it”.
But that is me. 😄
Terence Eden’s Blog (npub1y66…eusx)
m@thias.hellqui.st :verified-skull: /
npub1zj…szq0u
2024-06-25 12:44:40
in reply to nevent1q…qtty
Author Public Key
npub1zjlsclfq0nq8csh8mtap9qey9mhyp3em7nghljcw9hkhjpy5dt7qfszq0uPublished at
2024-06-25 12:44:40Event JSON
{
"id": "f04cc1f3623ac77243c3f7c2d05dbf58e3744b4ffa5048d5bc3e09126ce24d07",
"pubkey": "14bf0c7d207cc07c42e7dafa1283242eee40c73bf4d17fcb0e2ded7904946afc",
"created_at": 1719319480,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"d03ac19c048373cc1b9e0e53df4bc4025629cde705b1e37bc1f6278832573b51",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"350b4da116bd4aa32feaa4d36a4aa69b544e430946c2a9fa1ac43b3342652b3e"
],
[
"p",
"14bf0c7d207cc07c42e7dafa1283242eee40c73bf4d17fcb0e2ded7904946afc"
],
[
"p",
"26b431e4e38902b1e39b19b3fb6c2355da758511a0cd035720c73320a2546a31"
],
[
"e",
"483039f7354dcc2de9254b358e7d11bd8f9d45a03aa527610c0a8e54b89ca6e4",
"",
"root"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://thias.hellqui.st/objects/25ff41b4-601e-41c0-8351-662786ab1190",
"activitypub"
],
[
"L",
"pink.momostr"
],
[
"l",
"pink.momostr.activitypub:https://thias.hellqui.st/objects/25ff41b4-601e-41c0-8351-662786ab1190",
"pink.momostr"
],
[
"expiration",
"1721911484"
]
],
"content": "Mmm…you say “can”. I’m thinking we should consider if it “should”. I predict a *lot* of spammy broadcasting posts otherwise. People can obviously sift by chosing not to follow those accounts but…\n\nIt would make sense to be able to control the audience of a post, that indeed seems to be a requested feature, but personally I fail to see why I should be able to broadcast to “everyone” and then just pick a handful of people who can interact with my post. \n\nThe other way around, I am thinking if I limit who can interact with my post, it should **also** *only* be delivered to those people. It kind of “comes with the deal”. It also sounds rather fair (which obviously will be the main reason to why it’ll never happen).\n\nTo me, the general rule would be: “if you can read it you can interact with it”.\n\nBut that is me. 😄\n\nnostr:npub1y66rre8r3yptrcumrxelkmpr2hd8tpg35rxsx4eqcuejpgj5dgcslreusx",
"sig": "93a734a84658389f08c4a8df0875610be949bd24957904108e4a3a03edd13fd91191cbea6ee8d8de714f30e541c468ab8664081081d3b6f0ede6adac4834f858"
}