I mean, did you thoroughly read the article you just linked? It proves MY point about duplicate entries.
“The data provided to AP was imperfect in other ways. Among those people fully identified, some were listed twice by the ministry.“ Over 500 people in March, alone.
Okay, let’s try it another way. If I provide a number to the media and then later say that 50% of those records are, well, incomplete, you’re saying that’s not the same as revising the number down by half. You saying it’s okay to provide incomplete data because of the fog of war.
That’s NOT how fatality reporting works.
I’ve already shown you the implausibility of their figures, the impossibility of arriving at accurate numbers so quickly, and at least one actual example of a number (500 in a hospital) that was blamed on Israel, which was revised down (to 100-300), and later found to be the responsibility of Hamas’ own rockets hitting it’s own armaments depot in the parking lot of said hospital. And yet you continue to swallow their numbers as gospel?
I shudder to imagine the double standards that would be applied to Israel if they claimed a higher number of casualties and then said their records were “incomplete” when examined.
To wit, Hamas sympathizers deny the *actual* atrocities committed on 10/7 (murders, rapes, beheadings, and immolations) even as they were live streaming and celebrating them.
This whole this is just so twisted.
JayLeClay / j'ai les clés
npub13h…vhjry
2024-07-15 20:08:54
in reply to nevent1q…8r24
Author Public Key
npub13hgvezq9gm04a9hqs3uzmv869tm3wk26ql2tf3q037j59zk76c7spvhjryPublished at
2024-07-15 20:08:54Event JSON
{
"id": "274296802055dbee8b7ad92e4289dd2627db1c181592939f048465b4147f47ab",
"pubkey": "8dd0cc880546df5e96e084782db0fa2af717595a07d4b4c40f8fa5428aded63d",
"created_at": 1721074134,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"a721c632b046cc047081ea0cf78a4c5a16d3610e93d4343365d43301257b7c29",
"wss://relay.primal.net",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"0bfdc383e0b11305f1b8351927ac631239a2cd8f376326c53cea99c327ecfe13",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"58c741aa630c2da35a56a77c1d05381908bd10504fdd2d8b43f725efa6d23196"
],
[
"p",
"d568d1f912256c5266e454b8eed45cc234ed6ddd2237ccf2d1b477288ead9c14"
]
],
"content": "I mean, did you thoroughly read the article you just linked? It proves MY point about duplicate entries.\n“The data provided to AP was imperfect in other ways. Among those people fully identified, some were listed twice by the ministry.“ Over 500 people in March, alone. \n\nOkay, let’s try it another way. If I provide a number to the media and then later say that 50% of those records are, well, incomplete, you’re saying that’s not the same as revising the number down by half. You saying it’s okay to provide incomplete data because of the fog of war. \n\nThat’s NOT how fatality reporting works. \n\nI’ve already shown you the implausibility of their figures, the impossibility of arriving at accurate numbers so quickly, and at least one actual example of a number (500 in a hospital) that was blamed on Israel, which was revised down (to 100-300), and later found to be the responsibility of Hamas’ own rockets hitting it’s own armaments depot in the parking lot of said hospital. And yet you continue to swallow their numbers as gospel?\n\nI shudder to imagine the double standards that would be applied to Israel if they claimed a higher number of casualties and then said their records were “incomplete” when examined. \nTo wit, Hamas sympathizers deny the *actual* atrocities committed on 10/7 (murders, rapes, beheadings, and immolations) even as they were live streaming and celebrating them. \n\nThis whole this is just so twisted.",
"sig": "009d8919d5d1e7625824d5b40b8b14e565764ef2da347b62fea01673ec04f80a91878ccf3e7a85896542a712bf44f2724e5d9cccd909a58063ac3bc0e4436c35"
}