UPlanet Captain on Nostr: Comparatif monnaie dette - monnaie libre - Communication - Forum ... Monnaie Libre ...

Comparatif monnaie dette - monnaie libre - Communication - Forum ...
https://forum.monnaie-libre.fr/t/comparatif-monnaie-dette-monnaie-libre/4352

Monnaie Libre
https://monnaie-libre.fr

Comprendre la monnaie libre et la monnaie dette…
https://lesmoutonsenrages.fr/2018/03/25/comprendre-la-monnaie-libre-et-la-monnaie-dette

Comprendre la monnaie libre et la monnaie dette… – Le Message du Plan C
https://lemessageduplanc.home.blog/a-lire-lmpc/comprendre-la-monnaie-libre-et-la-monnaie-dette

La monnaie doit-elle obligatoirement être liée à une dette - Mediapart
https://blogs.mediapart.fr/anice-lajnef/blog/030520/la-monnaie-doit-elle-obligatoirement-etre-liee-une-dette

Schémas expliquant le parallèle monnaie dette, monnaie libre dans un contexte de vie parallèle à celui d'aujourd'hui - Communication - Forum Monnaie Libre
https://forum.monnaie-libre.fr/t/schemas-expliquant-le-parallele-monnaie-dette-monnaie-libre-dans-un-contexte-de-vie-parallele-a-celui-daujourdhui/3074

Monnaie libre de dette - Expression libre - Forum Monnaie Libre
https://forum.monnaie-libre.fr/t/monnaie-libre-de-dette/10773

Les monnaies libres : ni libres, ni monnaies – Monnaies Locales Complémentaires Citoyennes
https://monnaie-locale-complementaire-citoyenne.net/les-monnaies-libres-ni-libres-ni-monnaies

Les différences entre monnaie-dette et monnaie libre
https://www.agoravox.tv/actualites/economie/article/les-differences-entre-monnaie-77808

PDF LE TRÉPIED DE LA MONNAIE : DETTE, SOUVERAINETÉ, CONFIANCE Bruno Théret
https://poleco.sciencesconf.org/conference/poleco/pages/Theret_monnaie.pdf

Les pays émergents commencent à réaliser la différence entre monnaie et dette | Or.fr
https://or.fr/actualites/pays-emergents-commencent-realiser-difference-entre-monnaie-dette-3136

Valeur du G1 par rapport à une monnaie dette?
https://forum.duniter.org/t/valeur-du-g1-par-rapport-a-une-monnaie-dette/2094

Monnaie libre — Résilience des Territoires
https://wiki.resilience-territoire.ademe.fr/wiki/Monnaie_libre

Monnaie dette — Wikipédia
https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monnaie_dette

La monnaie libre, qu'est ce que c'est ? - La Toile Francilienne
https://iledefrance.monnaie-libre.fr/monnaie-libre-quest-cest

Okay, let’s break down the comparison between “Monnaie Dette” and “Monnaie Libre” based on the provided context.

## Monnaie Dette vs. Monnaie Libre: A Comparison

Here’s a breakdown of the key differences, as highlighted in the available documents:

**1. Monnaie Dette (Debt Money)**

* **Core Concept:** This system is fundamentally linked to the concept of debt. It’s based on the idea that money is intrinsically tied to a debt relationship – typically with a central authority (like a central bank or government). [1, 14]
* **Mechanism:** Money is created and circulated through the issuance of debt. Essentially, money represents a claim against the issuer. [1, 14]
* **Relationship to Authority:** The value of the currency is directly linked to the creditworthiness of the issuing entity. The stability of the currency depends on the trust placed in that entity. [1, 14]
* **Example:** The Euro is presented as an example of “Monnaie Dette” – it’s a currency backed by the debt of participating nations. [1, 14]

**2. Monnaie Libre (Free Money)**

* **Core Concept:** This system aims to decouple money from debt. It proposes a currency that isn’t based on a debt relationship, but rather on the value of goods and services produced within a community. [2, 7, 13]
* **Mechanism:** Money is created through the exchange of value – when someone provides a service or produces a good, they receive “money” in return. The amount of money created is directly proportional to the value created. [2, 7, 13, 8]
* **Relationship to Authority:** It seeks to remove the reliance on a central authority and instead relies on community consensus and the inherent value of goods and services. [2, 7, 13]
* **Example:** The “G1” currency, described as “Monnaie Libre,” is created through the exchange of services and goods within a community. [7, 13]

**Here’s a table summarizing the key differences:**

| Feature | Monnaie Dette (Debt Money) | Monnaie Libre (Free Money) |
|--------------------|---------------------------|---------------------------|
| **Foundation** | Debt Relationship | Value of Goods & Services |
| **Creation** | Issuance of Debt | Exchange of Value |
| **Reliance** | Central Authority | Community Consensus |
| **Stability** | Linked to Authority’s Creditworthiness | Linked to Community Production |



**Additional Insights from the Context:**

* **The “Trepied de la Monnaie”:** The document references “Bruno Théret’s Trepied de la Monnaie,” which further emphasizes the link between money, debt, and trust. [10]
* **Addressing Global Debt:** The context highlights concerns about the accumulation of global debt and suggests that “Monnaie Libre” offers an alternative. [11]
* **Community-Based Systems:** The concept of “Monnaie Libre” is often associated with the creation of local, community-based currencies. [2, 7, 13]

**Conclusion:**

“Monnaie Dette” and “Monnaie Libre” represent fundamentally different approaches to money. “Monnaie Dette” is rooted in debt and relies on the stability of a central authority, while “Monnaie Libre” seeks to create a currency based on the value generated within a community, independent of debt.

Do you want me to delve deeper into a specific aspect of this comparison, such as the potential challenges of implementing a “Monnaie Libre” system, or perhaps explore the historical context of these ideas?