Chris Trottier on Nostr: LLMs like Chat-GPT have a lot of potential as a game. They shouldn't be used for ...
LLMs like Chat-GPT have a lot of potential as a game.
They shouldn't be used for advice or fact-checking. By themselves, they're not good for writing stories. Pure and simple, they are a game. Specifically, they're textual adventure games with a sandbox.
I've said this previously, even likening it to "Zork + Grand Theft Auto".
In fact, I remember playing something similar on the Commodore 64 called ELIZA. I think it was meant to be a virtual therapist of sorts, but 11-year-old me spent a lot of time using it as a "practice girlfriend". If my parents only knew what I did with ELIZA 😅
I don't think apps like Chat-GPT are that much different from ELIZA, and they have the same limitations.
11-year-old me quickly realized that I had to put a lot of effort into getting ELIZA to say what I wanted it to, and that's the same deal with Chat-GPT. If you want it to do anything interesting, you have to coax it. And this is a lot of work.
Nevertheless, if you set the right parameters, the results can be interesting. I've created adventure games about:
* a dangerous gang of ducks overrunning a small town
* a film noir about watching paint dry
* a yakuza boss who makes all decisions based on what happens with his tamagotchi
But again, you can't let the LLM drive the creativity. It's not a good idea generator. But when you give it certain conditions, the result can be fun.
Published at
2023-06-04 21:07:21Event JSON
{
"id": "47180021193de58f9f82f77d4ac7db2707e8d09bc9489c3c75f67540ef9cc3da",
"pubkey": "d372b5815f23ec0faa965c0961bd2e4c3238fd54828a0f5334a87c3dd0fc9e2d",
"created_at": 1685912841,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"mostr",
"https://calckey.social/notes/9flhafbiiwwhqugg"
]
],
"content": "LLMs like Chat-GPT have a lot of potential as a game.\n\nThey shouldn't be used for advice or fact-checking. By themselves, they're not good for writing stories. Pure and simple, they are a game. Specifically, they're textual adventure games with a sandbox. \n\nI've said this previously, even likening it to \"Zork + Grand Theft Auto\". \n\nIn fact, I remember playing something similar on the Commodore 64 called ELIZA. I think it was meant to be a virtual therapist of sorts, but 11-year-old me spent a lot of time using it as a \"practice girlfriend\". If my parents only knew what I did with ELIZA 😅\n\nI don't think apps like Chat-GPT are that much different from ELIZA, and they have the same limitations.\n\n11-year-old me quickly realized that I had to put a lot of effort into getting ELIZA to say what I wanted it to, and that's the same deal with Chat-GPT. If you want it to do anything interesting, you have to coax it. And this is a lot of work. \n\nNevertheless, if you set the right parameters, the results can be interesting. I've created adventure games about: \n\n* a dangerous gang of ducks overrunning a small town\n* a film noir about watching paint dry\n* a yakuza boss who makes all decisions based on what happens with his tamagotchi\n\nBut again, you can't let the LLM drive the creativity. It's not a good idea generator. But when you give it certain conditions, the result can be fun.",
"sig": "6046a760e4fa78a00093b3becf3c6b4b76e06aa534ac6b29f18d8e0d6329998dd64c15e8043b97ce691845f5fe83b013a2efa4881525ce5f77fe9a26141d94ea"
}