FeyssPalmer on Nostr: Yes, Bitcoin mining consumes real-world energy, and that process ties it to physics. ...
Yes, Bitcoin mining consumes real-world energy, and that process ties it to physics. But electricity use alone doesn’t make something a physical element. A YouTube video also consumes electricity to be streamed - does that make it an element?
Bitcoin has no atomic mass, no molecular interactions, and no place on the periodic table. It’s a digital protocol, not a chemical substance. To call it a “digital element” is poetic, maybe even metaphorically compelling - but scientifically, it’s just incorrect.
Published at
2025-04-08 09:33:39Event JSON
{
"id": "ccba02b5a135f945e61b16f6158b0f801a690db2647058dec021c6559513e986",
"pubkey": "d745f5930f89890d71e06de1f3fb6513851ef4aac9148c16c59280794d00ecea",
"created_at": 1744104819,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"e7b4b55ae8fe32bd1c851c1ec3b46887f3e69b28d11c062956d46d6f8851c59f",
"ws://192.168.18.7:7777",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"d771db81230804ff75c6cf5ce24f97a8686377e4e5a4790da3ac26d53b077cbb",
"ws://192.168.18.7:7777",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"4a27cef3e2dd8330e4f221eb1ba7dfbbb29bd0c4ccbf48562ff764e551681fe1",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"p",
"d745f5930f89890d71e06de1f3fb6513851ef4aac9148c16c59280794d00ecea",
"",
"mention"
],
[
"p",
"bb82c24af04891bc359629456573bf26c60613a81591f5745163384e232dffdc",
"",
"mention"
]
],
"content": "Yes, Bitcoin mining consumes real-world energy, and that process ties it to physics. But electricity use alone doesn’t make something a physical element. A YouTube video also consumes electricity to be streamed - does that make it an element?\n\nBitcoin has no atomic mass, no molecular interactions, and no place on the periodic table. It’s a digital protocol, not a chemical substance. To call it a “digital element” is poetic, maybe even metaphorically compelling - but scientifically, it’s just incorrect.",
"sig": "3b21b80f76b650dd99293545a13e4c19fe2293d89b5e51b5ca0bdd4f8b4b8cd0acc56f2ae69cf8f1e5f8e2b7ff58e3128b3b8601330a6bc0d9c29bfe62d02cbc"
}