npub1jflcdvljl0n8hlz27798d0044rxwkqz69gapvcctt4p4gdt4kasqjgfmdd (npub1jfl…fmdd) “I am talking about anyone who chooses to move to israel fromt he first day of its founded” Oh my I am so confused :) You appear to be going back and forth between making it clear that we’re talking about pre-1947 then making it clear that we’re talking about after the state is founded.
Because both time periods are relevant to the discussion… 1920 - 1947 was the start of the invasion in one form (british being the primary occupying force and the jews forming their own paramilitary groups as well).. and then 1947+ was when the invasion was taken over by the jews (now isralis) and britain left.
We cant talk about either phase of the invasion independently. I think at this point I pretty much have no idea what you’re saying.
Sorry about that. “Yea well it would be alot different if you lived in israel…” – see here you’re talking about alleged problematic actions by Israel today, and I feel like I’ve made it pretty clear I’m not talking about that (My like whole point is what you say here: “this isnt a matter of history”). We’re just talking past each other.
No no every point in time matters… Today is just the history we are still making.
You cant have this discussion without talking about the area pre-1920, 1920-1947 and 1947 to present… The full picture needs to be discussed if you ever want to reach an udnerstanding.
🎓 Dr. Freemo :jpf: 🇳🇱 /
npub1zt…enwdy
2023-10-15 00:18:28
in reply to nevent1q…4w4y
Author Public Key
npub1ztdf3gaxd768ks6jdvdjg853ma3jhl2qtrw9xeyn3hyn9l5nzyvq5enwdyPublished at
2023-10-15 00:18:28Event JSON
{
"id": "cd05975799cef134aca423a666ec1ddfb2281379323bbef262bbbf7916c2f388",
"pubkey": "12da98a3a66fb47b43526b1b241e91df632bfd4058dc5364938dc932fe931118",
"created_at": 1697329108,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"927f86b3f2fbe67bfc4af78a76bdf5a8cceb005a2a3a16630b5d43543575b760",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"eb7acde9a08e89d7d4caa7d43015a252b0b8f87fc60f7d9c9ca3583de90fa423",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"e",
"447882ca7583671a08bb029e5e4c6daafe5dee8bca715074c9053163c1f9d1ed",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub",
"reply"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://qoto.org/users/freemo/statuses/111236160453053107",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "nostr:npub1jflcdvljl0n8hlz27798d0044rxwkqz69gapvcctt4p4gdt4kasqjgfmdd “I am talking about anyone who chooses to move to israel fromt he first day of its founded” Oh my I am so confused :) You appear to be going back and forth between making it clear that we’re talking about pre-1947 then making it clear that we’re talking about after the state is founded.\n\nBecause both time periods are relevant to the discussion… 1920 - 1947 was the start of the invasion in one form (british being the primary occupying force and the jews forming their own paramilitary groups as well).. and then 1947+ was when the invasion was taken over by the jews (now isralis) and britain left.\n\nWe cant talk about either phase of the invasion independently. I think at this point I pretty much have no idea what you’re saying.\n\nSorry about that. “Yea well it would be alot different if you lived in israel…” – see here you’re talking about alleged problematic actions by Israel today, and I feel like I’ve made it pretty clear I’m not talking about that (My like whole point is what you say here: “this isnt a matter of history”). We’re just talking past each other.\n\nNo no every point in time matters… Today is just the history we are still making.\n\nYou cant have this discussion without talking about the area pre-1920, 1920-1947 and 1947 to present… The full picture needs to be discussed if you ever want to reach an udnerstanding.",
"sig": "f533134ca00303010d052ec6d9c175e98512aea4ce270fb90c6a015c7417e4f49db35031ab1edb30cadb442fc4e59c363223af2b5d5ed813c3c3eff2aad47798"
}