1. The change is much smaller than other soft forms and is a well-scoped change (vs a large sweeping change). It does not introduce new utxos. It introduces new ways to encumber coins
2. The activation for bip345 is currently unspecified. It is not seeking a one month activation.
3. Im not sure what you mean about the other lock time. What are the downsides you want to have discussed?
4. I disagree. OP_VAULT would let individual HODLers massively upgrade their security without a lot of operational complexity. Individual users could have a single phone wallet or hardware wallet that implements a vault and falls back to more complex recovery paths. So you could have the ease of use of something like blue wallet but the theft resistance of a multisig
rot13maxi / Rijndael
npub1mx…u0htc
2023-04-19 11:26:10
in reply to nevent1q…0mz2
Author Public Key
npub1mxrssnzg8y9zjr6a9g6xqwhxfa23xlvmftluakxqatsrp6ez9gjssu0htcPublished at
2023-04-19 11:26:10Event JSON
{
"id": "b375b3f6e57934cbb7f236f8d6ea0522a007b5dbee720cbf61c0372cdd93524d",
"pubkey": "d987084c48390a290f5d2a34603ae64f55137d9b4affced8c0eae030eb222a25",
"created_at": 1681903570,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"44b8c3e86eeb5e19f2e1362e229081931fcf8d243f3fdcf1eb290d6123c3f6d2"
],
[
"e",
"07ebf6198bd6d5ae73d391171727a675315413a99423cc2332734bbed3860cdf"
],
[
"p",
"f4b3f3c86fe3d909e2ed6949d8df26848cb839f343ae6fbbeca61f89d09aac9e"
]
],
"content": "1. The change is much smaller than other soft forms and is a well-scoped change (vs a large sweeping change). It does not introduce new utxos. It introduces new ways to encumber coins\n\n2. The activation for bip345 is currently unspecified. It is not seeking a one month activation. \n\n3. Im not sure what you mean about the other lock time. What are the downsides you want to have discussed?\n\n4. I disagree. OP_VAULT would let individual HODLers massively upgrade their security without a lot of operational complexity. Individual users could have a single phone wallet or hardware wallet that implements a vault and falls back to more complex recovery paths. So you could have the ease of use of something like blue wallet but the theft resistance of a multisig ",
"sig": "2217e586e9f594aeab836117f7dacdd02d8042d703e644e2d95f72c85b575aaca63915dc197a582a4e9f08644d951532c44a7504f128235287df17089a772763"
}