TheGreatReassessment on Nostr: The shared narrative Americans had through the 1950s has disintegrated. A stable ...
The shared narrative Americans had through the 1950s has disintegrated. A stable society needs a common god. I think Trump, whether deliberately or not, is trying to bring that back by returning American idealism.
If you’ve read Neil Postman, he talks a lot about why public schooling makes no sense anymore. At least without a shared narrative or a common god that provides meaning to the question, “what are we even doing here?”
Kids in schools today are in a system that can’t tell them what the greater mission is except, so you can join a market economy. A market economy makes a poor god.
As Postman says, schools don’t serve the public, they create the public. In the United States, we’ve lost the pursuance of virtues and knowledge that a kid can aspire to because he know doesn’t where he’s supposed to go.
If Trump, can stoke the flames that bring a resurgence of Americanism, I think that’s a good thing. My only caveat is that I think it should be based upon transparency and truth. A pride in our culture, our land, our freedom, our history, our people, is a good thing, but it should not be uninformed and ignorant.
This is where the Bitcoin ethos can help.
Imagine celebrating with your neighbors the best of American idealism COMBINED with a government that can invite the inspection of its citizens with alacrity.
That is a vision of paradise I’m willing to fight for in the here and now.
This does not contradict my beliefs as Christian. Jesus is still and will be King forevermore. I will still share the Gospel and speak out against sin.
But the project of running a civil society must allow for people to be free to choose that on their own to choose and act in their own self-interest so long as it doesn’t violate the safety and property of another.
People need a shared narrative to give them meaning. If a civilization goes without it for too long, it will crumble.
Published at
2025-02-13 04:53:35Event JSON
{
"id": "3179e1086a858745d99b54d2ea53200d6828f08116f3fb5323d4e786c7198bf2",
"pubkey": "bd94574f1b8f3579b63a77edfb05ca41d4d14a9176d1a4547c9fa21b8b1ebf7c",
"created_at": 1739422415,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [],
"content": "The shared narrative Americans had through the 1950s has disintegrated. A stable society needs a common god. I think Trump, whether deliberately or not, is trying to bring that back by returning American idealism.\n\nIf you’ve read Neil Postman, he talks a lot about why public schooling makes no sense anymore. At least without a shared narrative or a common god that provides meaning to the question, “what are we even doing here?”\n\nKids in schools today are in a system that can’t tell them what the greater mission is except, so you can join a market economy. A market economy makes a poor god.\n\nAs Postman says, schools don’t serve the public, they create the public. In the United States, we’ve lost the pursuance of virtues and knowledge that a kid can aspire to because he know doesn’t where he’s supposed to go. \n\nIf Trump, can stoke the flames that bring a resurgence of Americanism, I think that’s a good thing. My only caveat is that I think it should be based upon transparency and truth. A pride in our culture, our land, our freedom, our history, our people, is a good thing, but it should not be uninformed and ignorant. \n\nThis is where the Bitcoin ethos can help. \n\nImagine celebrating with your neighbors the best of American idealism COMBINED with a government that can invite the inspection of its citizens with alacrity.\n\nThat is a vision of paradise I’m willing to fight for in the here and now.\n\nThis does not contradict my beliefs as Christian. Jesus is still and will be King forevermore. I will still share the Gospel and speak out against sin. \n\nBut the project of running a civil society must allow for people to be free to choose that on their own to choose and act in their own self-interest so long as it doesn’t violate the safety and property of another. \n\nPeople need a shared narrative to give them meaning. If a civilization goes without it for too long, it will crumble.",
"sig": "4b6fee382942ae7148dc64100b55cf627c9f1efa6f0a49a85e7c178d4a08d6b1d611f292dbe5b7ce75f507ee2dc186c01fddb58d3a9b3a79973f04318ccc0a8c"
}