Just keep in mind that while yes using the Google Pixel is Google hardware and it may seem antithetical to degoogling, choosing any other device with any other OS other than GrapheneOS will still use Google and give them privileged system level access too.
CalyxOS and LineageOS both use Google services without a way to turn them off. Both also include privileged Google apps / services that are enabled by default. AOSP itself doesn't include Google Play. CalyxOS and LineageOS both add more Google apps/services to AOSP.
To clarify, they always use Google services even without microG. They use Google for connectivity checks, network time, attestation key provisioning, SUPL, DNS fallback (LineageOS only), PSDS (Pixel 6 and 7), eSIM activation and more enabled by default
GrapheneOS doesn't use Google services by default, because we don't add Google services and we replace the few used by the Android Open Source Project. See grapheneos.org/faq#default-c… and grapheneos.org/faq#other-con…. This is a very minor part of our work though and not the purpose of it. Purpose of GrapheneOS is not specifically avoiding Google services but WE DO AVOID using them AS THE DEFAULT SERVICES..
By default, we reroute location requests made by apps to Play services to our own implementation of the Google Play location service based on the OS location service. This means apps depending on Google Play location work without it on GrapheneOS by default.
It's not correct to sell the alternatives to GrapheneOS as 'degoogled'. More importantly, none preserves the security model or provides proper security patches.
With GrapheneOS Google Services are an option and one that if chosen can be used completely unprivileged and isolated like another app in the standard app sandbox.
If you don't want to we give the user complete control. Use them dont use them, the power is yours.
MetropleX [GrapheneOS] ⚡🟣
npub1gd…7cn8c
2023-04-05 22:16:29
in reply to nevent1q…664h
Author Public Key
npub1gd3h5vg6zhcuy5a46crh32m4gjkx8xugu95wwgj2jqx55sfgxxpst7cn8cPublished at
2023-04-05 22:16:29Event JSON
{
"id": "3351be465c96aa34f552cee6ea52faf893c0047dc7f28b8fe99bbe01e3dda257",
"pubkey": "43637a311a15f1c253b5d60778ab7544ac639b88e168e7224a900d4a41283183",
"created_at": 1680732989,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"c766c842b27ac4c902027dbd6a635f5fc071aca24d03e5c992c7568ddcc5bc1c"
],
[
"e",
"7c324aa075345f01bb7238ff9f50d9a893ac138e40c923918da727272116b29e"
],
[
"p",
"df57b4986a2c659965c3df95ca3fea3533a207b09bf2c55a70d406c7d049124f"
],
[
"p",
"caef2482c04bb9abc3ac6fcdd27347e092a63dc3724171056182567460cb54c3"
],
[
"r",
"grapheneos.org/faq#default-c…"
],
[
"r",
"grapheneos.org/faq#other-con…."
]
],
"content": "Just keep in mind that while yes using the Google Pixel is Google hardware and it may seem antithetical to degoogling, choosing any other device with any other OS other than GrapheneOS will still use Google and give them privileged system level access too.\n\nCalyxOS and LineageOS both use Google services without a way to turn them off. Both also include privileged Google apps / services that are enabled by default. AOSP itself doesn't include Google Play. CalyxOS and LineageOS both add more Google apps/services to AOSP.\n\nTo clarify, they always use Google services even without microG. They use Google for connectivity checks, network time, attestation key provisioning, SUPL, DNS fallback (LineageOS only), PSDS (Pixel 6 and 7), eSIM activation and more enabled by default\n\nGrapheneOS doesn't use Google services by default, because we don't add Google services and we replace the few used by the Android Open Source Project. See grapheneos.org/faq#default-c… and grapheneos.org/faq#other-con…. This is a very minor part of our work though and not the purpose of it. Purpose of GrapheneOS is not specifically avoiding Google services but WE DO AVOID using them AS THE DEFAULT SERVICES..\n\nBy default, we reroute location requests made by apps to Play services to our own implementation of the Google Play location service based on the OS location service. This means apps depending on Google Play location work without it on GrapheneOS by default.\n\nIt's not correct to sell the alternatives to GrapheneOS as 'degoogled'. More importantly, none preserves the security model or provides proper security patches.\n\nWith GrapheneOS Google Services are an option and one that if chosen can be used completely unprivileged and isolated like another app in the standard app sandbox.\n\nIf you don't want to we give the user complete control. Use them dont use them, the power is yours.",
"sig": "d1236a364a1ed907430a888d1ed8063780ea25c4a258a82f5db57fbc595d88a4f6ed13a50a91d5bcd7f3bcf862d00f95577d4cb8959cb9a8b3f9a77406af9401"
}