npub1jflcdvljl0n8hlz27798d0044rxwkqz69gapvcctt4p4gdt4kasqjgfmdd (npub1jfl…fmdd) “Of course they came with weapons.. what are YOU on about? On may 1947 they and a group “ – came from where? They were already there. But you know this? I don’t understand what you’re trying to do here.
No, there were very few isralis already there. Prior to the invasion there were about 160K Palestinian Jews, some of whom chose to stay palestinian at the start of the invasion. Contrast this with the 800K arabs in the area.
Once the invasion was announced (that is, the international community of jews, along with the UN, declared they would invade an annex half of palestine for themselves), The resulting population, as part of right-of-return, skyrocketed.
As a result of this invasion by the end of the year in 1947 (the invasion was made official earlier that year) the invading jewish population had more trippled in that short time to over 630.
So no they werent “already there” 2/3 of the invasion were jews from around the world who migrated there to participate in the invasion either as a settler to the newly stolen land, or as military themselves. Often a bit of both. “they are illegal immigrants” Again, what? When Jewish refugees were coming in like 1925 under the British you’re saying that was illegal? Can you give me a source on that? Was it illegal before the British took over?
Yes, the british had no rights to allow anyone to come, they were occupying Palestinian territory and they had no right to allow anyone in or out, or to occupy the space at all.
So while people may have come thinking it was legal, since the British occupation is illegitmate (as all occupations are) and only the native people had any right to allow immigration, yes they were wholly illegal as an occupying force. “defend their land and prevent the invasion and annexing of their land.” and “they just decalred one day half the country was theirs and then went in and took it….” No? The British, eager to get out, had to leave something behind when they left, so they partitioned according to where people lived at the time, yes? (or had the UN do it) There’s plenty to say regarding how the partition plan should have been done differently, of course, but I can’t fathom how it is a “literal invasion”.
No, it was not where they were living at the time. Arabs and jews were intermixed throughout the country. Yes there were some towns for one group or the other in some cases, but those towns were often intermixed among the landscape.
Also, britain doesnt get to split up a country that already existed… their claim to palestine was as invalid as the Jews. The british didnt live there, only a population of citizens has any moral right to decide to split their country, and this is NOT what happened
🎓 Dr. Freemo :jpf: 🇳🇱 /
npub1zt…enwdy
2023-10-14 19:29:05
in reply to nevent1q…nwrv
Author Public Key
npub1ztdf3gaxd768ks6jdvdjg853ma3jhl2qtrw9xeyn3hyn9l5nzyvq5enwdyPublished at
2023-10-14 19:29:05Event JSON
{
"id": "3b82c526d55d8fa80c5f9cbbe4b9e1a9b194e60b41809f9b2fbd7bd423a1b5f5",
"pubkey": "12da98a3a66fb47b43526b1b241e91df632bfd4058dc5364938dc932fe931118",
"created_at": 1697311745,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"927f86b3f2fbe67bfc4af78a76bdf5a8cceb005a2a3a16630b5d43543575b760",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"eb7acde9a08e89d7d4caa7d43015a252b0b8f87fc60f7d9c9ca3583de90fa423",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"e",
"cb3d416e4efe1d051ed2796edde9562a93751304476b2a848bdff51d7cc72aee",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub",
"reply"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://qoto.org/users/freemo/statuses/111235022498467725",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "nostr:npub1jflcdvljl0n8hlz27798d0044rxwkqz69gapvcctt4p4gdt4kasqjgfmdd “Of course they came with weapons.. what are YOU on about? On may 1947 they and a group “ – came from where? They were already there. But you know this? I don’t understand what you’re trying to do here.\n\nNo, there were very few isralis already there. Prior to the invasion there were about 160K Palestinian Jews, some of whom chose to stay palestinian at the start of the invasion. Contrast this with the 800K arabs in the area.\n\nOnce the invasion was announced (that is, the international community of jews, along with the UN, declared they would invade an annex half of palestine for themselves), The resulting population, as part of right-of-return, skyrocketed.\n\nAs a result of this invasion by the end of the year in 1947 (the invasion was made official earlier that year) the invading jewish population had more trippled in that short time to over 630.\n\nSo no they werent “already there” 2/3 of the invasion were jews from around the world who migrated there to participate in the invasion either as a settler to the newly stolen land, or as military themselves. Often a bit of both. “they are illegal immigrants” Again, what? When Jewish refugees were coming in like 1925 under the British you’re saying that was illegal? Can you give me a source on that? Was it illegal before the British took over?\n\nYes, the british had no rights to allow anyone to come, they were occupying Palestinian territory and they had no right to allow anyone in or out, or to occupy the space at all.\n\nSo while people may have come thinking it was legal, since the British occupation is illegitmate (as all occupations are) and only the native people had any right to allow immigration, yes they were wholly illegal as an occupying force. “defend their land and prevent the invasion and annexing of their land.” and “they just decalred one day half the country was theirs and then went in and took it….” No? The British, eager to get out, had to leave something behind when they left, so they partitioned according to where people lived at the time, yes? (or had the UN do it) There’s plenty to say regarding how the partition plan should have been done differently, of course, but I can’t fathom how it is a “literal invasion”.\n\nNo, it was not where they were living at the time. Arabs and jews were intermixed throughout the country. Yes there were some towns for one group or the other in some cases, but those towns were often intermixed among the landscape.\n\nAlso, britain doesnt get to split up a country that already existed… their claim to palestine was as invalid as the Jews. The british didnt live there, only a population of citizens has any moral right to decide to split their country, and this is NOT what happened",
"sig": "062ee98543b827711bd8c867f16d9c809f2d46df1ca54eaffb0cce943a4fe6a9ee8f8a8f5111d0bdc4fada5e79891bd9082ff13e9cb0ca2c6c74f6a0c1e64f01"
}