Some thoughts
1. bip345 introduced a new utxo which is new, unprecedented, and not in a minor scope. Change is Too big.
2. bip345 seeks fast activation, and inevitable activation, but after only one month, it seems that the author has made significant changes to it, including detail implementation. Too hurry.
3. only discuss the benefits without reciprocity, and avoid discussing the disadvantages of its misuse. Compares are Not even for other time lock method
4. It is very beneficial for institutional users, but not friendly enough for individual users, which exacerbates inequality. A simple one like watch tower is not practically implementable for most of the individual users
dlmarie / dlmair
npub17j…eg4ha
2023-04-18 23:23:57
in reply to nevent1q…p35a
Author Public Key
npub17jel8jr0u0vsnchdd9ya3hexsjxtsw0ngwhxlwlv5c0cn5y64j0q0eg4haPublished at
2023-04-18 23:23:57Event JSON
{
"id": "07ebf6198bd6d5ae73d391171727a675315413a99423cc2332734bbed3860cdf",
"pubkey": "f4b3f3c86fe3d909e2ed6949d8df26848cb839f343ae6fbbeca61f89d09aac9e",
"created_at": 1681860237,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"44b8c3e86eeb5e19f2e1362e229081931fcf8d243f3fdcf1eb290d6123c3f6d2"
],
[
"p",
"d987084c48390a290f5d2a34603ae64f55137d9b4affced8c0eae030eb222a25"
]
],
"content": "Some thoughts \n\n1. bip345 introduced a new utxo which is new, unprecedented, and not in a minor scope. Change is Too big.\n\n2. bip345 seeks fast activation, and inevitable activation, but after only one month, it seems that the author has made significant changes to it, including detail implementation. Too hurry.\n\n3. only discuss the benefits without reciprocity, and avoid discussing the disadvantages of its misuse. Compares are Not even for other time lock method \n\n4. It is very beneficial for institutional users, but not friendly enough for individual users, which exacerbates inequality. A simple one like watch tower is not practically implementable for most of the individual users",
"sig": "3f8a1929f11b1cc015559895cfd2e2ec9f5dc88dfd65b0e9969f208048ad843ef7db9c952929c2fda77168dc1d2618ec4d70dceb9e86bccae10109ca43fba1a4"
}