LpLiberto on Nostr: I’m by no means trying to destroy the argument or being cynical, just thinking as ...
I’m by no means trying to destroy the argument or being cynical, just thinking as the discussion moves along. This is all in good faith!
I don’t see a path to UBI without centralisation of resources and redistribution by a central authority. If force is deemed unacceptable, then it must rely on generous donations. If force is deemed acceptable, well…
Of course any group could decide to organise in such a centralised way and to voluntarily give up capital for the common good, but what about the next generation, or any free rider that wouldn’t want to contribute?
Anyway I can stop, I really don’t mean to harass you! My focus and priority is on voluntaryism and individual freedom, so I’m always curious to see what works and not in such a framework.
Published at
2024-03-28 19:31:10Event JSON
{
"id": "87204802353a98937da95fff906e3d23659db3be353decfa9aa5cb27ae67b85a",
"pubkey": "f665062b993a8d8f1b058a2d85e8ae63e91329cb1e96f3cb58644c138e6f755a",
"created_at": 1711654270,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"6522e33cd6c4528e29496d6f7207f33ee78dc790035457909869f278da5de988",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"df06d21eca7c19c89d054964b2d9e305a425ebde34403cb0e7966a872b23058f"
],
[
"e",
"7b4edb3bb55ef66a87a4db31e0e249195bb8678e7b61d8ab76abe4edf872800e",
"",
"root"
]
],
"content": "I’m by no means trying to destroy the argument or being cynical, just thinking as the discussion moves along. This is all in good faith!\n\nI don’t see a path to UBI without centralisation of resources and redistribution by a central authority. If force is deemed unacceptable, then it must rely on generous donations. If force is deemed acceptable, well…\n\nOf course any group could decide to organise in such a centralised way and to voluntarily give up capital for the common good, but what about the next generation, or any free rider that wouldn’t want to contribute?\n\nAnyway I can stop, I really don’t mean to harass you! My focus and priority is on voluntaryism and individual freedom, so I’m always curious to see what works and not in such a framework.",
"sig": "ae68ea46d74e4bb78db32fe058b0d75671cccc19bfcc7cc8131c939f0e01ec34cbb2a71a7e08665f5f30bc9cd2dadae0f857640afbada39bc8e2257003d0f647"
}