Michael Harris once claimed I had mathematical privilege, when I pointed out in a review that his writings come across as *incredibly* privileged (being invited to govt soirées in Paris, Ivy league background and position etc). I of course have only an adjunct academic position and have never lived outside Australia. My work is pretty obscure in a niche topic and I trouble envisioning my papers ending up in top journals as a result (I don't do mainstream differential geometry, or number theory, or PDEs or whatever is the thing that carries the most weight in the big-name general journals).
However, somehow, I have acquired privilege, despite all that. It struck me that I could email a number of leading figures in the mathematics community who through accidents of time know me, and expect a decent answer. I also have a relatively large platform in mathematical social media, I guess merely out of sheer persistence, but not because I aimed to.
I'm grateful for this privilege and the responsibility it gives me is something that only sometimes comes to mind. I know there are many people out there that do not have what I have, in this regard, and I shouldn't forget it.
So yes, I have a form of privilege. I cannot envy Michael Harris, it doesn't get me anywhere. The joy I get from doing mathematics and talking about it doesn't depend on me being an Ivy League professor.
theHigherGeometer /
npub1d6…5mhwm
2025-02-14 03:58:02
Author Public Key
npub1d60hhaertjrlmhefe54s00hfyga38wangrqthcu3zdnnnfm3myase5mhwmPublished at
2025-02-14 03:58:02Event JSON
{
"id": "8cc20646a7784469c8b15cba30260c62e380784bde1aa1796dbc4a02bd1e84eb",
"pubkey": "6e9f7bf7235c87fddf29cd2b07bee9223b13bbb340c0bbe391136739a771d93b",
"created_at": 1739505482,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"proxy",
"https://mathstodon.xyz/@highergeometer/114000231317050084",
"web"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://mathstodon.xyz/users/highergeometer/statuses/114000231317050084",
"activitypub"
],
[
"L",
"pink.momostr"
],
[
"l",
"pink.momostr.activitypub:https://mathstodon.xyz/users/highergeometer/statuses/114000231317050084",
"pink.momostr"
],
[
"-"
]
],
"content": "Michael Harris once claimed I had mathematical privilege, when I pointed out in a review that his writings come across as *incredibly* privileged (being invited to govt soirées in Paris, Ivy league background and position etc). I of course have only an adjunct academic position and have never lived outside Australia. My work is pretty obscure in a niche topic and I trouble envisioning my papers ending up in top journals as a result (I don't do mainstream differential geometry, or number theory, or PDEs or whatever is the thing that carries the most weight in the big-name general journals).\n\nHowever, somehow, I have acquired privilege, despite all that. It struck me that I could email a number of leading figures in the mathematics community who through accidents of time know me, and expect a decent answer. I also have a relatively large platform in mathematical social media, I guess merely out of sheer persistence, but not because I aimed to.\n\nI'm grateful for this privilege and the responsibility it gives me is something that only sometimes comes to mind. I know there are many people out there that do not have what I have, in this regard, and I shouldn't forget it.\n\nSo yes, I have a form of privilege. I cannot envy Michael Harris, it doesn't get me anywhere. The joy I get from doing mathematics and talking about it doesn't depend on me being an Ivy League professor.",
"sig": "e2b108232b98368552ee927d9791d5dde7867f36ecdb0810bb57fe9bd85c4ccc01919c34a9440c3cdddb9e17506916dd6689d704437014d9477405e0f6769603"
}