AITA, academic publishing edition.
Journal sends a review back to me because when I did not run the code and replicate the results.
My response: "As an unpaid anonymous peer reviewer who handles probably 30 manuscripts a year, I am absolutely not in the position of running and evaluating code any more than I am in the position of running gels to evaluate lab results. If this is important to you, I suspect you can find a consultant who will do it at a reasonable rate."
Am I the asshole?
Carl T. Bergstrom /
npub143…amxgy
2023-09-16 22:49:20
Author Public Key
npub1432qfqea0tlke6l54ltr95m8encxg3cwnttj3drme697d0amjk9q4amxgyPublished at
2023-09-16 22:49:20Event JSON
{
"id": "8cf63955a6f319ae647148c27ed8ca577f4eda9ca093f417cf66ffa8af7d91b3",
"pubkey": "ac5404833d7aff6cebf4afd632d367ccf064470e9ad728b47bce8be6bfbb958a",
"created_at": 1694904560,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"proxy",
"https://fediscience.org/users/ct_bergstrom/statuses/111077265291261923",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "AITA, academic publishing edition.\n\nJournal sends a review back to me because when I did not run the code and replicate the results. \n\nMy response: \"As an unpaid anonymous peer reviewer who handles probably 30 manuscripts a year, I am absolutely not in the position of running and evaluating code any more than I am in the position of running gels to evaluate lab results. If this is important to you, I suspect you can find a consultant who will do it at a reasonable rate.\"\n\nAm I the asshole?",
"sig": "302645cc9c667570bf1ba6f4457822c1199d6a484f221127213a35806e0bfeb4c075c71474fd4d8bad96275413cdf475d2595da123a7ebd14811055a704cae93"
}