Like many other technologists, I gave my time and expertise for free to #StackOverflow because the content was licensed CC-BY-SA - meaning that it was a public good. It brought me joy to help people figure out why their #ASR code wasn't working, or assist with a #CUDA bug.
Now that a deal has been struck with #OpenAI to scrape all the questions and answers in Stack Overflow, to train #GenerativeAI models, like #LLMs, without attribution to authors (as required under the CC-BY-SA license under which Stack Overflow content is licensed), to be sold back to us (the SA clause requires derivative works to be shared under the same license), I have issued a Data Deletion request to Stack Overflow to disassociate my username from my Stack Overflow username, and am closing my account, just like I did with Reddit, Inc.
https://policies.stackoverflow.co/data-request/
The data I helped create is going to be bundled in an #LLM and sold back to me.
In a single move, Stack Overflow has alienated its community - which is also its main source of competitive advantage, in exchange for token lucre.
Stack Exchange, Stack Overflow's former instantiation, used to fulfill a psychological contract - help others out when you can, for the expectation that others may in turn assist you in the future. Now it's not an exchange, it's #enshittification.
Programmers now join artists and copywriters, whose works have been snaffled up to create #GenAI solutions.
The silver lining I see is that once OpenAI creates LLMs that generate code - like Microsoft has done with Copilot on GitHub - where will they go to get help with the bugs that the generative AI models introduce, particularly, given the recent GitClear report, of the "downward pressure on code quality" caused by these tools?
While this is just one more example of #enshittification, it's also a salient lesson for #DevRel folks - if your community is your source of advantage, don't upset them.
Kathy Reid /
npub1sd…ns240
2024-05-10 00:12:39
Author Public Key
npub1sda95zgzx6zarhzv9x5kay3xh0qy99tl0qypyrefmt76pzcke96qgns240Published at
2024-05-10 00:12:39Event JSON
{
"id": "8c27e93542a2b95b00e165b24445942133df379e2bcca3107b0a7b0f8b7a3106",
"pubkey": "837a5a09023685d1dc4c29a96e9226bbc042957f7808120f29dafda08b16c974",
"created_at": 1715299959,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"t",
"llms"
],
[
"t",
"cuda"
],
[
"t",
"stackoverflow"
],
[
"t",
"asr"
],
[
"t",
"generativeai"
],
[
"t",
"enshittification"
],
[
"t",
"genai"
],
[
"t",
"devrel"
],
[
"t",
"openai"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://aus.social/@KathyReid/112413898118066645",
"web"
],
[
"t",
"llm"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://aus.social/users/KathyReid/statuses/112413898118066645",
"activitypub"
],
[
"L",
"pink.momostr"
],
[
"l",
"pink.momostr.activitypub:https://aus.social/users/KathyReid/statuses/112413898118066645",
"pink.momostr"
]
],
"content": "Like many other technologists, I gave my time and expertise for free to #StackOverflow because the content was licensed CC-BY-SA - meaning that it was a public good. It brought me joy to help people figure out why their #ASR code wasn't working, or assist with a #CUDA bug. \n\nNow that a deal has been struck with #OpenAI to scrape all the questions and answers in Stack Overflow, to train #GenerativeAI models, like #LLMs, without attribution to authors (as required under the CC-BY-SA license under which Stack Overflow content is licensed), to be sold back to us (the SA clause requires derivative works to be shared under the same license), I have issued a Data Deletion request to Stack Overflow to disassociate my username from my Stack Overflow username, and am closing my account, just like I did with Reddit, Inc. \n\nhttps://policies.stackoverflow.co/data-request/\n\nThe data I helped create is going to be bundled in an #LLM and sold back to me. \n\nIn a single move, Stack Overflow has alienated its community - which is also its main source of competitive advantage, in exchange for token lucre. \n\nStack Exchange, Stack Overflow's former instantiation, used to fulfill a psychological contract - help others out when you can, for the expectation that others may in turn assist you in the future. Now it's not an exchange, it's #enshittification. \n\nProgrammers now join artists and copywriters, whose works have been snaffled up to create #GenAI solutions. \n\nThe silver lining I see is that once OpenAI creates LLMs that generate code - like Microsoft has done with Copilot on GitHub - where will they go to get help with the bugs that the generative AI models introduce, particularly, given the recent GitClear report, of the \"downward pressure on code quality\" caused by these tools? \n\nWhile this is just one more example of #enshittification, it's also a salient lesson for #DevRel folks - if your community is your source of advantage, don't upset them.",
"sig": "c6bcd07394906ab228e9a0a8c67dd0b84101ae27ea6547a4599de5a8c100ea9c41684edf2587d583cad728b4b402e631f1bb7a2be0f8be3c17bbeb6b8cd5ab00"
}