yeah, i just watched that entire video, it looks a little more complicated than sparrow / whirlpool, nice UI, but it’s not as simple as like pay one fee and wait - sort of seems like you have to keep making transactions, and keep paying that fee
i think i just need to become a bit more comfortable with the fee structure and i’ll be all good though
when he looks at the outputs it’s interesting how they aren’t all the same value, there’s a mix of matching values
i did a quick search on samourai twitter to see what they mention about joinmarket (because they usually don’t beat around the bush when it comes to criticising shit)
they seem to place it below whirlpool but above samaurai, almost feels like their opinion might be “if you’re not going to whirlpool, probably should use joinmarket”
i think the only concern my simple brain could make sense of was that joinmarket reuses liquidity, so i think whirlpool is waiting for fresh liquidity to remix, but joinmarket you could technically be mixing with the same handful people over and over, so it’s not seen really as a gain to the anonymity set
could be completely wrong there tho, that was just what i could gather from a quick look, i’ll keep looking
yort
npub156…03y3s
2023-06-23 11:43:00
in reply to nevent1q…lddd
Author Public Key
npub156ndcn2xqlav8wrty2gk8x9qtmen7wx2uhl2hmrxsvkwq2duza2sw03y3sPublished at
2023-06-23 11:43:00Event JSON
{
"id": "9af30fd3d0252f1821616850579df3292f611eb033c236ab3b6d7606d61e1543",
"pubkey": "a6a6dc4d4607fac3b86b22916398a05ef33f38cae5feabec66832ce029bc1755",
"created_at": 1687520580,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"0aac24e9226a3286c06040607d578238940aea2a85aeef6207bf0d8722379641"
],
[
"e",
"1c8acc16ea5c08f72c97d0bbcec6baf1ea9472e71b8521ee406958707f66fc17"
],
[
"p",
"1989034e56b8f606c724f45a12ce84a11841621aaf7182a1f6564380b9c4276b"
],
[
"p",
"7ca66d4166b16f54a16868191ba1c6386a976624f4634f3896d9b6740a388ca3"
]
],
"content": "yeah, i just watched that entire video, it looks a little more complicated than sparrow / whirlpool, nice UI, but it’s not as simple as like pay one fee and wait - sort of seems like you have to keep making transactions, and keep paying that fee\n\ni think i just need to become a bit more comfortable with the fee structure and i’ll be all good though\n\nwhen he looks at the outputs it’s interesting how they aren’t all the same value, there’s a mix of matching values\n\ni did a quick search on samourai twitter to see what they mention about joinmarket (because they usually don’t beat around the bush when it comes to criticising shit)\n\nthey seem to place it below whirlpool but above samaurai, almost feels like their opinion might be “if you’re not going to whirlpool, probably should use joinmarket”\n\ni think the only concern my simple brain could make sense of was that joinmarket reuses liquidity, so i think whirlpool is waiting for fresh liquidity to remix, but joinmarket you could technically be mixing with the same handful people over and over, so it’s not seen really as a gain to the anonymity set\n\ncould be completely wrong there tho, that was just what i could gather from a quick look, i’ll keep looking",
"sig": "f3d3dca8d3f282d276b824f687f42052b8309ea24bb8ce95681e1d7685e1b3b24f576159e738f372377baf78b72efa8fa70d76f04e09d6a3a80fe51b70813c43"
}