npub1xkwaswarxtyfywx0exf0ve9kheuzj4c6py745r6fvfm0nfz6ctlsne7jwu (npub1xkw…7jwu) npub1gcwrmxkclgvxl3adj40aaw0kegtrwr9k6rtw9heyyaajg6y5q0xql9hx0z (npub1gcw…hx0z) npub19g7p8kyl5mmj3kpu0s09glqnncc49cv34v7ev636jzthyu6u20cqt50dwd (npub19g7…0dwd) neuroscience group (npub1d6e…vw9g)
I love these historical examples! And sorry if I'm being dense here, but in what way was Kepler pseudoscientific? He took Copernicus's idea and Brahe's data and formulated his 3 laws; those equations made predictions about where the planets would be in the future that could be tested (And as you said, those laws triggered some of Newton's ideas about why the planets move as they do).
Is the pseudoscience here the absence of an account of "why the planets do it that way?"
In contrast, IIT appears to be prescientific insofar as most of its predictions cannot be empirically tested at all (as I understand it).
Nicole Rust /
npub1cu…0zuw2
2023-09-17 19:47:54
in reply to nevent1q…s7mt
Author Public Key
npub1cud99prgj4etl597aaxthxenrcjmfxl92dgj8snf9a9p8ctupfyq80zuw2Published at
2023-09-17 19:47:54Event JSON
{
"id": "dcbe5a826a1340cbf62b3c423a99cf3f8a83d68bd0e176f1fb22664c8be5b510",
"pubkey": "c71a5284689572bfd0beef4cbb9b331e25b49be5535123c2692f4a13e17c0a48",
"created_at": 1694980074,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"359dd83ba332c89238cfc992f664b6be7829571a093d5a0f496276f9a45ac2ff",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"461c3d9ad8fa186fc7ad955fdeb9f6ca16370cb6d0d6e2df24277b24689403cc",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"2a3c13d89fa6f728d83c7c1e547c139e3152e191ab3d966a3a909772735c53f0",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"6eb315a9d0d6094d3e5fcad641e12128e416324fbb1be53ccd4fce2f058e975a",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"931d80e8806aa8e388c02733a74bf7bbbef68e9350568fe63034ee1c42458353",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"e",
"95032cda6ef45369879cccfd185ef0efc9a9833f8598bc09234fb70dec6098e4",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub",
"reply"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://neuromatch.social/users/NicoleCRust/statuses/111082214170477234",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "nostr:npub1xkwaswarxtyfywx0exf0ve9kheuzj4c6py745r6fvfm0nfz6ctlsne7jwu nostr:npub1gcwrmxkclgvxl3adj40aaw0kegtrwr9k6rtw9heyyaajg6y5q0xql9hx0z nostr:npub19g7p8kyl5mmj3kpu0s09glqnncc49cv34v7ev636jzthyu6u20cqt50dwd nostr:npub1d6e3t2ws6cy560jlettyrcfp9rjpvvj0hvd720xdfl8z7pvwjadqqtvw9g \n\nI love these historical examples! And sorry if I'm being dense here, but in what way was Kepler pseudoscientific? He took Copernicus's idea and Brahe's data and formulated his 3 laws; those equations made predictions about where the planets would be in the future that could be tested (And as you said, those laws triggered some of Newton's ideas about why the planets move as they do).\n\nIs the pseudoscience here the absence of an account of \"why the planets do it that way?\"\n\nIn contrast, IIT appears to be prescientific insofar as most of its predictions cannot be empirically tested at all (as I understand it).",
"sig": "7d48d8f56179fab72b481e48982f9c03d452157cb2413a6d8e6bfc3c37dd2b2c768cf47ef583e4a3d774ce89a3af93d0a4df8fec37bc7e8eac8d08d6b94ce42f"
}