#AIArtDiscussion #AIArt
I just had a thought about the whole topic. Some people say AI Art is Art, because the "Artist" is providing the prompt. If the AI is really creating Art, on an abstract level it's not different from commissioning an artist. They create the art, based on your descriptions. In German Law (I don't know about other countries), there is a difference between the Creator and the Copyright Holder. The creator automatically has the copyright, but he can sign it off to another person. That signing off is a legal process. But an AI isn't a person. It can't enter into a contract. So the commissioner can't acquire the copyright from it. But the AI itself can't hold a copyright, as it isn't a person. So all AI Art should be copyright free.
AvisJay /
npub1hc…ylq25
2024-01-03 14:00:48
Author Public Key
npub1hcs4s5uauvgvtfk3d5ltadjvkjdqt69s0cdx7ucgm5rglrvddjksaylq25Seen on
wss://relay.noswhere.comPublished at
2024-01-03 14:00:48Event JSON
{
"id": "dc33794cf2d96fd222d6d00884003b36a9d95f48500d0e95edee3b28aa8246ee",
"pubkey": "be2158539de310c5a6d16d3ebeb64cb49a05e8b07e1a6f7308dd068f8d8d6cad",
"created_at": 1704290448,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"t",
"aiartdiscussion"
],
[
"t",
"aiart"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://squawk.social/users/avis_jay/statuses/111692378803772345",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "#AIArtDiscussion #AIArt\nI just had a thought about the whole topic. Some people say AI Art is Art, because the \"Artist\" is providing the prompt. If the AI is really creating Art, on an abstract level it's not different from commissioning an artist. They create the art, based on your descriptions. In German Law (I don't know about other countries), there is a difference between the Creator and the Copyright Holder. The creator automatically has the copyright, but he can sign it off to another person. That signing off is a legal process. But an AI isn't a person. It can't enter into a contract. So the commissioner can't acquire the copyright from it. But the AI itself can't hold a copyright, as it isn't a person. So all AI Art should be copyright free.",
"sig": "b5eb89f8e0f487f87bbb38de4a95d77cc983b9767971901dfde4db1e923283715bbf5f0c9a9843da69a562db1b4659e8b19ed0cdf8f54437c9bcf023bae88223"
}