š
Original date posted:2022-06-08
š Original message:I think Jorge's request for specifics is reasonable. I agree that we
can raise the level of discussion. Each claim about how good or bad a
specific BIP is should say why on the technical merits. Comments on
prior claims may expose misinformation, expose "trust me" authority,
or point out other fallacies. They should include a citation of the
original source, a fair restatement of the problematic claim for
current readers, and a short explanation of why it doesn't advance
understanding technical consensus.
There have been lots of mean comments. Some "Truth and
Reconciliation" will come due, and it will be a huge amount of work.
Another history book?
Ryan Grant [ARCHIVE] /
npub19aā¦6mwcl
2023-06-07 23:10:15
in reply to nevent1qā¦2pkl
Author Public Key
npub19a2m7qm80t7mzhgqfgunswhm5c3q4fkqt89057ugy7u8jdxncf2q06mwclPublished at
2023-06-07 23:10:15Event JSON
{
"id": "567a1e3f9a8a07892ae8bae50e64e092848b634ab029db8a517cd31d1d3d6ee6",
"pubkey": "2f55bf03677afdb15d004a39383afba6220aa6c059cafa7b8827b87934d3c254",
"created_at": 1686179415,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"5551b13e7da6b3f09c0d99802a19f9d792bb6230bb9f7b81382a9edb07abfa59",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"627c8115569ee6df131272fe630cba85fe257579e9ca5ccd40e4a658fb7bd034",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"3030ec2d70259fdd55ba8e063740c139c3daaa618f86e3fae34cebcb73c742ba"
]
],
"content": "š
Original date posted:2022-06-08\nš Original message:I think Jorge's request for specifics is reasonable. I agree that we\ncan raise the level of discussion. Each claim about how good or bad a\nspecific BIP is should say why on the technical merits. Comments on\nprior claims may expose misinformation, expose \"trust me\" authority,\nor point out other fallacies. They should include a citation of the\noriginal source, a fair restatement of the problematic claim for\ncurrent readers, and a short explanation of why it doesn't advance\nunderstanding technical consensus.\n\nThere have been lots of mean comments. Some \"Truth and\nReconciliation\" will come due, and it will be a huge amount of work.\nAnother history book?",
"sig": "d20a5f810620ae89bc5ed77dbcef4bc0ecc9273c62501ae02b096fdebc3ae4a10187382ca0ad60ea2fa2ac34cb6cfae8286d0bfd256c4d27f21c059b5f926931"
}