brockm on Nostr: The weird thing I notice about some of the people who state they are most opposed to ...
The weird thing I notice about some of the people who state they are most opposed to identity politics, is how ironically -- and seemingly unknowingly -- they are enmeshed in extreme forms of it.
If your personal identity is tied to a belief system of any kind, and you consider attacks on that belief system to be a personal attack. And, you tend to constrain your personal relationships to people who share that belief system, you are simply part of identity politics. That is what identity politics is.
It doesn't really matter what the belief system is: if it's progressive or "woke" politics. Or right-wing populist politics. Or even if it's categories like bitcoiner vs nocoiner -- if your personal behavior, and community behaviors fit the definition I laid out in the second paragraph, then you are participating in identity politics.
And yes, identity politics is pretty bad for anything resembling a functioning pluralistic society.
Published at
2023-05-03 22:21:41Event JSON
{
"id": "55af375915b786f69b1a47c00f75b7372035139b2983fe8b6bc54b9af16285bb",
"pubkey": "b9003833fabff271d0782e030be61b7ec38ce7d45a1b9a869fbdb34b9e2d2000",
"created_at": 1683152501,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [],
"content": "The weird thing I notice about some of the people who state they are most opposed to identity politics, is how ironically -- and seemingly unknowingly -- they are enmeshed in extreme forms of it. \n\nIf your personal identity is tied to a belief system of any kind, and you consider attacks on that belief system to be a personal attack. And, you tend to constrain your personal relationships to people who share that belief system, you are simply part of identity politics. That is what identity politics is. \n\nIt doesn't really matter what the belief system is: if it's progressive or \"woke\" politics. Or right-wing populist politics. Or even if it's categories like bitcoiner vs nocoiner -- if your personal behavior, and community behaviors fit the definition I laid out in the second paragraph, then you are participating in identity politics. \n\nAnd yes, identity politics is pretty bad for anything resembling a functioning pluralistic society. ",
"sig": "c9108ade365b75d47b5175c79b0c9dc387c74122dd127b2b36080d049548ef55d9733408c8b86d0524b2950b65b0fe507024b7c5137c2dc2857302feb8cfa7a1"
}