Rick Wesson [ARCHIVE] on Nostr: 📅 Original date posted:2011-12-16 🗒️ Summary of this message: Slush prefers ...

📅 Original date posted:2011-12-16
🗒️ Summary of this message: Slush prefers standard URLs for Bitcoin addresses, finding other proposals like DNS mapping or email aliases converted to URLs strange.
📝 Original message:On Thu, Dec 15, 2011 at 4:07 PM, slush <slush at centrum.cz> wrote:
> I really like this proposal with standard URLs. All other proposals like DNS
> mapping or email aliases converted to URLs with some weird logic looks
> strange to me.

wow, really. Maybe you could review some RFCs, there are thousands of
examples where some really smart engineers chose the exact opposite
path which you propose below.

-rick

> Plain URLs (returning address in response body, redirecting to URI
> "bitcoin:<address>" or anything else) are very clear solution, easy to
> implement in clients and very easy to understand by people. It's also
> extremely flexible - almost everybody can somewhere setup static file
> containing his "personal" addresses or it's very easy to integrate such
> solution with eshops (providing custom address for given order) etc. I'm
> definitely for this solution.
>
> Best,
> slush
>
> On Tue, Dec 13, 2011 at 5:22 PM, Andy Parkins <andyparkins at gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> On 2011 December 13 Tuesday, Amir Taaki wrote:
>>
>> > Maybe I wasn't clear enough in the document, but this is the intent with
>> > the HTTPS proposal.
>>
>> I don't like the idea of a hard-coded mapping at all.  We shouldn't be
>> making
>> choices on behalf of server operators.  It's up to them how they arrange
>> their
>> domain names and paths.
>>
>> I also agree that DNS is not the technology to use.  DNS is a nightmare.
>>
>> > genjix at foo.org
>> >
>> > Contacts https://foo.org/bitcoin-alias/?handle=genjix and the system
>> > responds with a bitcoin address. Whether the system gives you a new
>> > address from a pool of addresses, or contacts the merchant behind the
>> > scenes is implementation defined.
>> >
>> > I'll clarify it later. This is the relevant line:
>> >
>> > string strRequestUrl = strDomain + "/bitcoin-alias/?handle=" +
>> > pszEncodedNick;
>> >
>> > Between HTTPS service and server service, I lean slightly towards HTTPS
>> > (automatic encrypted connection, CAs + all benefits of DNS). But still
>> > interested in arguments in favour of a server service (daemon answering
>> > queries).
>>
>> Why bother with an encoding scheme at all?  If the address
>>
>>  genjix at foo.org
>>
>> always maps to
>>
>>  https://foo.org/bitcoin-alias/?handle=genjix
>>
>> Then forget the hardcoding of "https" the hardcoding of "bitcoin-alias"
>> and
>> "?handle=" and the original email-looking "genjix at foo.org".  Just use the
>> URL.
>> Then the author of the service can use whatever they want.
>>
>>  "Can I pay you 10 BTC?"
>>  "Sure, send it to 'https://bitcoinalias.foo.org/genjix/'";
>>
>> While I might implement my alias server like this:
>>
>>  "Sure, send it to 'https://google.com/bitcoin/?andyparkins'";
>>  "Sure, send it to 'https://parkins.co.uk/";
>>
>> ... or any other URL they want -- any of which suit might suit me and my
>> webserver better than whatever mapping would otherwise be hard-coded.  The
>> world is already very familiar with URLs so this is no more scary than the
>> email address.  What's more, the email address form looks _too much_ like
>> an
>> email address, and will only lead to confusion ... "send it to
>> genjix at foo.org"
>> "so I use outlook express for that, right?"  "erm, no, you put it in your
>> bitcoin client".
>>
>> The URL form could easily be made to detect a browser connecting rather
>> than a
>> bitcoin client (and this is an area that would benefit from a standards
>> document -- define the headers and user agent triggers that an alias
>> server
>> expects) and give them better instructions.
>>
>> https can be specified as the default, so  "https://"; can be optional when
>> they're typing.  If, in the future, bitcoin gets a distributed
>> peer-to-peer
>> alias system, then a new URL type can be added easily
>> "bcalias://andyparkins"
>> might automatically find my node in the network and query it for an
>> address
>> (or whatever).
>>
>> All of the above is exactly why OpenID chose to use URLs for ID.
>>
>>
>>
>> Andy
>>
>> --
>> Dr Andy Parkins
>> andyparkins at gmail.com
>>
>>
>> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>> Systems Optimization Self Assessment
>> Improve efficiency and utilization of IT resources. Drive out cost and
>> improve service delivery. Take 5 minutes to use this Systems Optimization
>> Self Assessment. http://www.accelacomm.com/jaw/sdnl/114/51450054/
>> _______________________________________________
>> Bitcoin-development mailing list
>> Bitcoin-development at lists.sourceforge.net
>> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bitcoin-development
>>
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> Learn Windows Azure Live!  Tuesday, Dec 13, 2011
> Microsoft is holding a special Learn Windows Azure training event for
> developers. It will provide a great way to learn Windows Azure and what it
> provides. You can attend the event by watching it streamed LIVE online.
> Learn more at http://p.sf.net/sfu/ms-windowsazure
> _______________________________________________
> Bitcoin-development mailing list
> Bitcoin-development at lists.sourceforge.net
> https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bitcoin-development
>