Bitcoin and Nostr are examples of individuals getting up, rolling up their sleeves and taking their freedoms without permission.
quoting
naddr1qv…d5p6I’m sure you are all well aware of the news out of France. The French government has made the bold move of arresting the founder of Telegram, Pavel Durov, after charging him with 12 criminal counts ranging from “complicity in web-mastering an online platform in order to enable an illegal transaction in organized group” to “importing a cryptology tool ensuring authentication or integrity monitoring without prior declaration”.
Telegram is an extremely popular messaging app that is used by almost 1 billion people from around the world. I have personally been a user for seven years and it is very dismaying to see the French government attack an entrepreneur who has built a widely used and loved app. We’ve said it many times over the years in this rag, governments need to stop throwing the baby out with the bath water by attacking successful businesses for the crimes their users commit and begin doing better law enforcement. It makes no sense to demonize a technology for the crimes that are committed by a small minority of users of that tool. Is the French government going to go after the CEO of Bic, the largest producer of pens in the world, because there are pen pals out there who use their pens to write letters in which they coordinate criminal activity? If we apply the same logic behind the decision to arrest Pavel it would seem that the Bic CEO should be a bit worried.
Who knows what evidence the French government has against Pavel. Maybe he is directly involved in the coordination of crimes that were committed on his app. I highly doubt it, but who knows. We’ll have to wait and see what evidence the French courts put forth once a trial gets under way. As of yesterday, we know that this seems like a classic case of “You refuse to cooperate with deep state actors who want access to your users’ data, so we’re going to accuse you of all of the crimes.”
The fact of the matter is, we shouldn’t have to worry about the actions of a founder dictating the accessibility of a novel technology that they bring to market. Especially technologies that enable people to connect in the digital world to exercise their God given right to free speech.
It’s a bit poetic that this happened on Saturday night in Europe. Just one day after the Nostriga conference in Riga, Latvia wrapped up. Nostriga was a two-day event which attracted people from all over the world so that they could meet to discuss how to push the Nostr protocol forward. For those who are unaware of what Nostr is, it is an open source communications protocol with no leaders that enables individuals to publish their thoughts to the world is a distributed, censorship resistant fashion. User profiles are created via a private-public key pair. The public key makes it easy for others to follow and the private key enables a user to sign notes with certain data that get broadcasted to relays. App developers can then pull the user generated data from those relays and present the data in unique ways using front-end interfaces known as clients. Users can port their private keys (commonly known as nsecs) into any client they like and have all of the data they’ve published to the protocol automatically show up. Said another way, since Nostr is a protocol and not a platform, users have way more optionality when it comes to the applications that present the data they publish. If one client decides to censor or simply has a bad UX, they can plop their magic string (private key) into another client and see everything they’ve ever posted while still being connected to everyone they added to their social graph historically. This is extremely powerful on many fronts.
Gone are the days of having to worry about building an audience on a platform, making that a critical part of your brand and livelihood, and having to self-censor because of the fear of being deplatformed. You own your private key and that gives you access to your data. Not the platform.
For app developers, the network effect of Nostr produces an incredible and truly unique bootstrapping mechanism. Instead of having to start from scratch and hope that users find your app, fill it with data, and begin spreading the word to more users you adopt the social graph of Nostr from day one. Every user of the protocol is already feeding your application data. If you can build an appealing product that provides users of the protocol with value, they will find it and immediately be able to leverage it. There will be no need for them to build up a reputation or find their social connections on the app. They will be ported into the client.
Nostr can be additive to seemingly unrelated applications that aren’t built directly on Nostr. We’ve already seen this with bitcoin wallets that have enabled users to port their Nostr social graphs directly into their wallet. Making it easy for individuals to find their friend’s Nostr account and send bitcoin directly to the lightning address they’ve associated with it. No need for an invoice. Just find your friend and send them money like you would on an app like Venmo.
The number of added benefits users and app developers get from Nostr beyond those I just explained are too long to list. Long story short, this protocol is a massive deal.
It is still very early for Nostr, but the progress that has been made in the last couple of years has been nothing short of awe inspiring. If you squint into the future, it isn’t hard to see how Nostr becomes mainstream by the end of the decade. The compounding network effects are stronger than anything I’ve seen since bitcoin.
All of this is to say that this will be one of the only ways to build truly robust communications-based applications moving forward. As we’ve seen with TikTok and now Telegram, if the state doesn’t like the owner of a particular platform they will either kick the platform out of their country or arrest the founder and do their best to corrupt the platform itself once he is in custody. This hasn’t happened yet with Telegram, but you can bet your ass that the deep state will try to corrupt Telegram if they successfully remove him from the picture.
To be clear, this doesn’t make the founders of particular Nostr clients immune to this type of overt overreach by governments. However, the design of Nostr is such that governments would have an exponentially harder time achieving their end goal, suppressing and controlling speech that’s expressed on these platforms, because the protocol has hundreds of competing clients serving customers the data stored in relays. They could even attempt to go after the relays, but that task may prove to be impossible as well.
Make no mistake, we live in very trying times. The world’s governments are losing control and they are doing the best they can to suppress freedom of speech in anyway they can to prevent people from spreading information that makes the Regime to look like the evil fools that they are. The best we can do is to build robust systems that make their attempts at suppressing speech as close to impossible as is possible. The efforts to build out robust systems like bitcoin and Nostr should be complemented with pushing back against the Regime via the courts. But as we all know, we can’t always depend on the courts to actually deliver justice. There are times where freedom must be taken and defended. We are certainly living through one of those times right now.
Despite the insanity of the world and the governments who would like to rule it, the momentum of the light is building. People are taking action and solutions are being built slowly but surely. It is our job to keep the momentum up and make sure the lifeboats of bitcoin, Nostr and similar protocols are ready to go once the Deep State begins attacking others. They came for TikTok and Telegram. Don’t think that platforms like X, Rumble and Gab aren’t in their crosshairs as well.
Here are four videos from Nostriga that I think you all should watch.
https://youtu.be/XUsk7cqZyKU?si=2vUl01azeFJQjczZ
https://youtu.be/qUwXRDrfJU0?si=np3vyTDddoQKuPJK
https://youtu.be/OHqxp-Hrx9k?si=K7vhVBWtFQwB68Tr
https://youtu.be/iZyqVGHjDGo?si=CjJCbAlNBa06qcwV
And a panel I hosted about funding Nostr if you’re interested in that.
https://youtu.be/qD-Y0fq5KiA?si=L81sFCPGw2ayXXzw
We’re going to win.
Final thought… Jet lag sucks.