With regards to incorrect self-tagging, yeah that sucks. Some people will get that wrong. I don't think removing all options for self-tagging is a good idea though. And that's where a common language goes a long way to helping relays and clients know what they are dealing with.
As for gaming the reporting, that will always be a risk, for sure. But it's not intractable. Reputation goes a long way, operators and moderators can be weary of reports from pub keys that have no history on their relay, etc. Tooling is key here.
When you say "you can even moderate, and censor your community with your own rules" and then say "it doesn't belong [...] arbitrary moderators making decisions", how are you reconciling those two ideas?
nickmonad /
npub1tl…uq0v6
2023-04-28 19:21:57
in reply to nevent1q…htsh
Author Public Key
npub1tln5mjd8xjd7rqnfqp7cu77lwkvcd89kwllr7fu5a0vzru2xl6qssuq0v6Published at
2023-04-28 19:21:57Event JSON
{
"id": "7c9b179f8a3edc06ca576f5e82e7a686595943c6e5551907713de7008ef558c0",
"pubkey": "5fe74dc9a7349be18269007d8e7bdf7599869cb677fe3f2794ebd821f146fe81",
"created_at": 1682709717,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"62b0ec228be9c8afc1d21fe0deb0075259fa08ed8269142266ae057a6f0c3116"
],
[
"e",
"147ca77f6ab8fcf614a04d8e5cf7cf7edd0831ebc37f3ca299e4514d4dd8908e"
],
[
"e",
"ad54ae1c81eab8e68051d8c7f48d709db4bf5b46eda1ad82a480267a3d76f726"
],
[
"p",
"5fe74dc9a7349be18269007d8e7bdf7599869cb677fe3f2794ebd821f146fe81"
],
[
"p",
"b2dd40097e4d04b1a56fb3b65fc1d1aaf2929ad30fd842c74d68b9908744495b"
]
],
"content": "With regards to incorrect self-tagging, yeah that sucks. Some people will get that wrong. I don't think removing all options for self-tagging is a good idea though. And that's where a common language goes a long way to helping relays and clients know what they are dealing with.\n\nAs for gaming the reporting, that will always be a risk, for sure. But it's not intractable. Reputation goes a long way, operators and moderators can be weary of reports from pub keys that have no history on their relay, etc. Tooling is key here.\n\nWhen you say \"you can even moderate, and censor your community with your own rules\" and then say \"it doesn't belong [...] arbitrary moderators making decisions\", how are you reconciling those two ideas?",
"sig": "5513378019733e23abe2a7c4ceed15ec09f96fff005e07f619d0ad429e669fc964c44cd4858473707c64277527365ff0562d309391208cd72a0c8e3c069fe3c5"
}