Indeed.
Imagine paying 5% coordinator fee to join 0.001 BTC Whirlpool, while Wasabi doesn't charge any coordinator fee for inputs below 0.01 BTC.
Wasabi is cheaper in coordinator fees unless a user has 12 * the pool denomination in the 2 biggest Whirlpools (0.5 & 0.05) or 17 * the pool denomination (0.01).
In Scamourai you get free remixes but in Wasabi you get free remixing even after 1 hop.
Whirlpool requires you to do 2 transactions, Tx0 and the actual cj, while Wasabi does it all in one to save on tx fees.
Tx0 produces a toxic change, while Wasabi doesn't, except for big whales.
To register multiple inputs to Tx0 you reveal the common input heuristic, which is very bad for users privacy, while in Wasabi all inputs are registered separately.
In Whirlpool you need to wait a lot to be able to remix, while in Wasabi you can do it very quickly.
Scamourai is older project than Wasabi but they still have only ~10% of the volume.
No wonder they are salty and they need to create confusion to stay in business.
BTCparadigm / Rafe
npub1g8…jgh4l
2023-03-09 12:05:49
in reply to nevent1q…lv4h
Author Public Key
npub1g8hswun8cny6fhve60qyzgtl4pa438tstptpzra48ju7mmfw3wjsrjgh4lPublished at
2023-03-09 12:05:49Event JSON
{
"id": "76fb62edf83ce38ce8e88312848856c6be0f4580b2821b4587fb434db25d6ef7",
"pubkey": "41ef077267c4c9a4dd99d3c041217fa87b589d705856110fb53cb9eded2e8ba5",
"created_at": 1678363549,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"3d4b1353a805459d03f76f3dd876bef403a48d7351db592ef74ae3b63aba2673",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"6ffec3f430d962f75d9af27f87dedb7900a5bb730c5db133d69256dee804e119",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"4857c8f167bd474fae0e7b54898d0c187ea9f1adb7ad02a9ff6a86d29abcb7ab"
],
[
"p",
"a4cb51f4618cfcd16b2d3171c466179bed8e197c43b8598823b04de266cef110"
],
[
"p",
"e88a691e98d9987c964521dff60025f60700378a4879180dcbbb4a5027850411"
]
],
"content": "Indeed.\n\nImagine paying 5% coordinator fee to join 0.001 BTC Whirlpool, while Wasabi doesn't charge any coordinator fee for inputs below 0.01 BTC.\n\nWasabi is cheaper in coordinator fees unless a user has 12 * the pool denomination in the 2 biggest Whirlpools (0.5 \u0026 0.05) or 17 * the pool denomination (0.01).\n\nIn Scamourai you get free remixes but in Wasabi you get free remixing even after 1 hop.\n\nWhirlpool requires you to do 2 transactions, Tx0 and the actual cj, while Wasabi does it all in one to save on tx fees.\n\nTx0 produces a toxic change, while Wasabi doesn't, except for big whales.\n\nTo register multiple inputs to Tx0 you reveal the common input heuristic, which is very bad for users privacy, while in Wasabi all inputs are registered separately.\n\nIn Whirlpool you need to wait a lot to be able to remix, while in Wasabi you can do it very quickly.\n\nScamourai is older project than Wasabi but they still have only ~10% of the volume. \n\nNo wonder they are salty and they need to create confusion to stay in business.",
"sig": "7ff51892209b503e5767725dd2a948d8fbb34a80182731a839dca26120561a2297ee69fda71584f7ea2113b50ffa4785ffa4d42f1825d83b023b49d53ec899cc"
}