The way I read craigraw (npub1hea…g9v2)’s feedback on Github is that the criticisms are more than pragmatic. He has a list of drawbacks. The lack of fountain encoding and well defined type structures (for example output descriptors) are the biggest gaps between UR and BBQr.
Many wallets like Blue Wallet, Nunchuck, and Green Wallet have adopted the BC UR standard. I don’t see what BBQr brings to the table for users of animated QRs. It doesn’t appear to solve anything for the end user over BC UR. What am I missing?
I’m not saying that BC UR is perfect. I could come up with a long list of things I wish were different about the BC UR standard.
newtonick / Nick Klockenga
npub1rf…l7wrt
2023-11-25 02:43:56
in reply to nevent1q…028a
Author Public Key
npub1rfd0hxdzcze6pzj29thuz34vur57wm9quje7w3edxjgusq6m47csnl7wrtPublished at
2023-11-25 02:43:56Event JSON
{
"id": "7d685436d0568bff310493001b306bb204b5a97e6b6657c8cb69821f309945e0",
"pubkey": "1a5afb99a2c0b3a08a4a2aefc146ace0e9e76ca0e4b3e7472d3491c8035bafb1",
"created_at": 1700880236,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"0d0c7f4caad1d9cfaeab6c5da6d942ec2ef2707e501d971182a0bba2f6151676"
],
[
"e",
"cb88551669e18ea5c56e953237925468db62460d78f5a7a7b0989ccbc151575e"
],
[
"p",
"04c915daefee38317fa734444acee390a8269fe5810b2241e5e6dd343dfbecc9"
],
[
"p",
"be7a5291b532e8b918f2dc98148948a33d3e0da07788d7416f73b4c7514f08e6"
],
[
"p",
"e88a691e98d9987c964521dff60025f60700378a4879180dcbbb4a5027850411"
],
[
"p",
"be7a5291b532e8b918f2dc98148948a33d3e0da07788d7416f73b4c7514f08e6"
]
],
"content": "The way I read nostr:npub1hea99yd4xt5tjx8jmjvpfz2g5v7nurdqw7ydwst0ww6vw520prnq6fg9v2’s feedback on Github is that the criticisms are more than pragmatic. He has a list of drawbacks. The lack of fountain encoding and well defined type structures (for example output descriptors) are the biggest gaps between UR and BBQr.\n\nMany wallets like Blue Wallet, Nunchuck, and Green Wallet have adopted the BC UR standard. I don’t see what BBQr brings to the table for users of animated QRs. It doesn’t appear to solve anything for the end user over BC UR. What am I missing?\n\nI’m not saying that BC UR is perfect. I could come up with a long list of things I wish were different about the BC UR standard.",
"sig": "c84746e45474463e6016047a00086898004a33f449b45fb6f043c2c08fee27e5df8ab9c50b5682166e61d893ac3738ee63406067e8f4373f13821ad6d3d01b05"
}