npub1cmgqvz7xr07euwkum3mjghjqcu4d3k2fcyf6g4uwwe5ggnd6fetq0wrzd2 (npub1cmg…rzd2) I don't want to get into a GitHub discussion, so I'll just add my 2 cents here. I really like the mockup and your reasoning. The default UI is just awful and your suggestions (and Bird UI!) are definitely a big step in the right direction.
One thing caught my eye, though: modal form. What was your reasoning to make it as a modal?
I've grown to like about the current UI because you can start writing a post and continue browsing at the same time. The form just stays there, but does not prevent you from doing something else.
It may just be me, but I find this very useful. Especially with longer posts, I often need to refer to other toots, and being able to do that without having to open multiple browser tabs is really nice.
I think modals can be great when there is a real reason to force the user to do only one thing at a time. However, writing a new toot does not feel like that. Writing shouldn't interfere with reading toots and notifications for no reason.
And yes, I know it is also possible to use multiple browser tabs and implement a stateful modal too, but that is not the point 😄
Anyways, great job! 👏
Mika Hiltunen /
npub1ty…a48d9
2023-12-01 07:04:22
in reply to nevent1q…mycw
Author Public Key
npub1tyum04l3e6ngvhmm6tufe3xrkm6tq392t573xm4kgfzzej0p2ddssa48d9Published at
2023-12-01 07:04:22Event JSON
{
"id": "f858fe248821ead7ea624da167abcb44fd18dada8685eca567f6407fc176dd17",
"pubkey": "5939b7d7f1cea6865f7bd2f89cc4c3b6f4b044aa5d3d136eb642442cc9e1535b",
"created_at": 1701414262,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"p",
"c6d0060bc61bfd9e3adcdc77245e40c72ad8d949c113a4578e7668844dba4e56",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"p",
"118cd39da270a800372ab7276a46b488cca3c40dd2b34f73b857fc8f72fae0f8",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub"
],
[
"e",
"327f0dc545c9d18a31b0399d9e9105c66258bdc23dbf57dbd5a3c0693d09538c",
"wss://relay.mostr.pub",
"reply"
],
[
"proxy",
"https://mementomori.social/users/saaste/statuses/111503885076281382",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "nostr:npub1cmgqvz7xr07euwkum3mjghjqcu4d3k2fcyf6g4uwwe5ggnd6fetq0wrzd2 I don't want to get into a GitHub discussion, so I'll just add my 2 cents here. I really like the mockup and your reasoning. The default UI is just awful and your suggestions (and Bird UI!) are definitely a big step in the right direction.\n\nOne thing caught my eye, though: modal form. What was your reasoning to make it as a modal?\n\nI've grown to like about the current UI because you can start writing a post and continue browsing at the same time. The form just stays there, but does not prevent you from doing something else.\n\nIt may just be me, but I find this very useful. Especially with longer posts, I often need to refer to other toots, and being able to do that without having to open multiple browser tabs is really nice.\n\nI think modals can be great when there is a real reason to force the user to do only one thing at a time. However, writing a new toot does not feel like that. Writing shouldn't interfere with reading toots and notifications for no reason.\n\nAnd yes, I know it is also possible to use multiple browser tabs and implement a stateful modal too, but that is not the point 😄\n\nAnyways, great job! 👏",
"sig": "1bd8b84b528a58c38b9dba855ffb9602f5dc902253b331e5925284cafd4fdc67266cee0da86645b9b3fcc45b944c438bf5936d103ef093a2792fd5d28b679785"
}