Terence Tao on Nostr: This morning I gave an answer to a MathOverflow question using traditional ...
This morning I gave an answer to a MathOverflow question using traditional pen-and-paper analysis:
https://mathoverflow.net/a/489533/766 . The answer was not in closed form, so I wanted to simulate it approximately. At this point I asked o3-mini-high for some code for this. Interestingly, it first declared that the quantity I was trying to compute was infinite (it wasn't), but nevertheless provided numerical code which did give a rough approximation to the quantity I wanted (to one decimal place):
https://chatgpt.com/share/67d71204-3510-800e-8bca-11bfbf53fc3d . At that point I figured out how to get a more precise answer (using the theory of Markov chains) and asked o3-mini-high again for more code for this. Interestingly, it was able to correct a basic error in the prompt (I had written max instead of min when writing a truncation), and gave me perfectly good code, which I was able to adapt to then give a more numerically precise answer to the MO question.
So all in all a pretty good assist from o3; it made a mistake that I corrected, but I also made a mistake that it corrected, and code that would have taken perhaps an hour of my time on my own was generated, tested, modified, and reported in maybe ten minutes.
Published at
2025-03-16 19:12:28Event JSON
{
"id": "f52df3d585abe5ca45bad5a81d15db41d72bc8753e2cf831c2694eda311f2cb2",
"pubkey": "bc13e579bf49294633747700e25eb4f71d0c2aa134e89f30d36d7e1630e1bba3",
"created_at": 1742152348,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"proxy",
"https://mathstodon.xyz/users/tao/statuses/114173696303072269",
"activitypub"
]
],
"content": "This morning I gave an answer to a MathOverflow question using traditional pen-and-paper analysis: https://mathoverflow.net/a/489533/766 . The answer was not in closed form, so I wanted to simulate it approximately. At this point I asked o3-mini-high for some code for this. Interestingly, it first declared that the quantity I was trying to compute was infinite (it wasn't), but nevertheless provided numerical code which did give a rough approximation to the quantity I wanted (to one decimal place): https://chatgpt.com/share/67d71204-3510-800e-8bca-11bfbf53fc3d . At that point I figured out how to get a more precise answer (using the theory of Markov chains) and asked o3-mini-high again for more code for this. Interestingly, it was able to correct a basic error in the prompt (I had written max instead of min when writing a truncation), and gave me perfectly good code, which I was able to adapt to then give a more numerically precise answer to the MO question.\n\nSo all in all a pretty good assist from o3; it made a mistake that I corrected, but I also made a mistake that it corrected, and code that would have taken perhaps an hour of my time on my own was generated, tested, modified, and reported in maybe ten minutes.",
"sig": "8951ca77082e282dc50d867b31413fa25e622c0ba84bc69167744172a78dc408a0ff955a863e0681de2bab8d35cebfcfcbf1db3d54262cd9cc5323339133e7eb"
}