Thanks for discussing!
My specific issue is, I've heard mwi described as saying there is no wave function collapse - all that happens is you, as an observer, end up in a branch that contains a single outcome from all the superposed possibilities - eg an electron hitting the detector at a certain place after going through alone slit or the other. It is implied that nothing special happens before this, and observation just strips out all the other possibilities ("destroys the worlds").
But the electron at the detector has the properties of a particle not a wave. If so something must have changed and the only thing that makes sense to me involves some sort of "collapse" from waves that can interfere, to particles that are detected. Which seems not to be allowed under mwi.
As an aside part of my interest in this is that I feel quantum mechanics may indicate a special role for the observer that puts it outside of the physical world, and can help make sense of many things in our experience that science hasn't been able to inform us on. More on this if you are interested!
pseudourinidine /
npub1jh…lfgps
2024-08-19 09:23:42
in reply to nevent1q…5lx7
Author Public Key
npub1jhpnh7aedv85v09cpahjug5aa460xm5kjnntqn0v2yjwfmmtmenqllfgpsPublished at
2024-08-19 09:23:42Event JSON
{
"id": "f7ea62d157021d9fbc3f0a6c170caad2cc0ecdef1d94f77e65f72d8c41160c4a",
"pubkey": "95c33bfbb96b0f463cb80f6f2e229ded74f36e9694e6b04dec5124e4ef6bde66",
"created_at": 1724059422,
"kind": 1,
"tags": [
[
"e",
"b9c34ded93aa44431aa9279fd0cf614aaa911b82cf8036c5b3f07528b5f50944",
"",
"root"
],
[
"e",
"32775bd7fe529dbf35b81ce6e39e6d3f2186d340d16c2fad381f2d8f72aeda37"
],
[
"e",
"555152a053b21cc7eb01fd33ebbca618f504e541c2fa30d5cfd36c88412dc517",
"",
"reply"
],
[
"p",
"c21b1a6cdb247ccbd938dcb16b15a4fa382d00ffd7b12d5cbbad172a0cd4d170"
],
[
"p",
"95c33bfbb96b0f463cb80f6f2e229ded74f36e9694e6b04dec5124e4ef6bde66"
]
],
"content": "Thanks for discussing!\n\nMy specific issue is, I've heard mwi described as saying there is no wave function collapse - all that happens is you, as an observer, end up in a branch that contains a single outcome from all the superposed possibilities - eg an electron hitting the detector at a certain place after going through alone slit or the other. It is implied that nothing special happens before this, and observation just strips out all the other possibilities (\"destroys the worlds\").\n\nBut the electron at the detector has the properties of a particle not a wave. If so something must have changed and the only thing that makes sense to me involves some sort of \"collapse\" from waves that can interfere, to particles that are detected. Which seems not to be allowed under mwi.\n\nAs an aside part of my interest in this is that I feel quantum mechanics may indicate a special role for the observer that puts it outside of the physical world, and can help make sense of many things in our experience that science hasn't been able to inform us on. More on this if you are interested!",
"sig": "2bae85b8940ef0d8fc1be85dfea448bfa5c510b2121bcb5a70ed3fa0b361fb397e071c8b36fdc89d2221bd3f66a65c212402fbc74fe8e560e067c9bc216eeaa2"
}